Keeping track of your cat’s litter box can be a major pain, but nothing makes it more of a pain than realizing that you’re overpaying for litter or that your current litter just isn’t working for your cat. Finding the right place to get your cat litter from can provide you with the freedom of a wide variety of options to suit your cat’s preferences. Finding a litter that controls bad odors, doesn’t get tracked all over your house, and doesn’t break the bank can be hard to do, so we’ve reviewed the best options for purchasing your cat litter, no matter what you’re looking for.
A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites of 2023
Image Product Details
Best Overall
Kitty Poo Club
Litter and litter box are shipped together
Each box and litter bag are made to last one cat for a month
Box made with recycled, and biodegradable components
Click to Save 25% Use code CAT25
Best Value
Chewy
Great customer service
Carry all types of cat litter
Large selection of products
Click & save 35%
Petco
Regularly offer discounts
Autoship is optional and discounted
Online and in-person shopping options
Check Price
Pretty Litter
Highly-reviewed product and service
Focuses exclusively on a specialty litter
Customer controls autoship frequency and litter quantity
Check Price
PetSmart
Regularly offer discounts
Payment plans are available
Same-day pickup and delivery
Check Price
The 8 Best Places to Buy Cat Litter in the US
1. Kitty Poo Club Cat Litter Subscription – Best Overall
Save 20% off first litter box order with code CAT20
Selection: +
Price range: $$
Subscription Optional
Autoship option: Yes
Kitty Poo Club is one of the most convenient options for cat litter because they ship a disposable litter box with enough litter for one cat for approximately a month right to your front door. They also sell a few types of litter and litter boxes separately, as well as cat food, treats, toys, and accessories. Customers can set up a subscription with auto-ship options if desired, but products can also be independently purchased. Their litter boxes are made with 100% recycled materials and are fully recyclable and biodegradable. This company’s products are a more expensive option for some people, especially if you have a multi-cat home.
Pros
Most convenient option
Litter and disposable litter box are shipped together
Each box and litter bag are made to last one cat for a month
Subscription and autoship are optional
Litter boxes are made with recycled, recyclable, and biodegradable components
Cons
Limited product selection
More expensive option for multi-cat homes
2. Chewy – Best Value
Click To Save 35% On Your First Autoship Order
Selection: +++++
Price range: $ – $$$
Subscription No
Autoship option: Yes
Chewy is a great place to buy cat litter if you want value for your money. This online company may not have any brick-and-mortar stores, but they have one of the largest cat litter selections available. They routinely offer coupons and sales, allowing you to get great deals on your cat’s litter. They carry everything from clumping clay litter to tofu litter, paper litter, and walnut shell litter. You do not need a subscription to purchase from Chewy and they provide a discounted auto-ship option to help you save even more money on cat litter. This company is known for its high quality of customer care and is constantly updating product options to maintain a broad selection of great items.
Most convenient option
Litter and disposable litter box are shipped together
Each box and litter bag are made to last one cat for a month
Subscription and autoship are optional
Litter boxes are made with recycled, recyclable, and biodegradable components
- Most convenient option
- Litter and disposable litter box are shipped together
- Each box and litter bag are made to last one cat for a month
- Subscription and autoship are optional
- Litter boxes are made with recycled, recyclable, and biodegradable components
Limited product selection
More expensive option for multi-cat homes
- Limited product selection
- More expensive option for multi-cat homes
Click To Save 35% On Your First Autoship Order
Selection: +++++
Price range: $ – $$$
Subscription No
Autoship option: Yes
Pros
Large selection of products
Regularly offer discounts
Carry all types of cat litter
No subscription required
Autoship is optional and discounted
Great customer service
Regularly updates products
Cons
Online only
- Petco
Visit Their Website
Selection: +++
Price range: $ – $$$
Subscription No
Autoship option: Yes
Petco is also a great place to buy cat litter. They have an online store and around 1,500 in-person stores. They offer same-day pickup, same-day delivery, and shipping with auto-ship options. A subscription is not required and they carry multiple kinds of litter from most major litter brands, although their selection is smaller than some other stores. They regularly run sales, offer coupons, and offer discounts to customers who have a free membership with the company. They have been in business for over 50 years and pride themselves in great customer service and high-quality products.
Large selection of products
Regularly offer discounts
Carry all types of cat litter
No subscription required
Autoship is optional and discounted
Great customer service
Regularly updates products
- Large selection of products
- Regularly offer discounts
- Carry all types of cat litter
- No subscription required
- Autoship is optional and discounted
- Great customer service
- Regularly updates products
Online only
- Online only
Visit Their Website
Selection: +++
Price range: $ – $$$
Subscription No
Autoship option: Yes
Pros
Online and in-person shopping options
Same-day pickup and delivery, as well as shipping to home
Autoship is optional and discounted
No subscription required
Carry most major litter brands
Regularly offer discounts
Great customer service
Cons
Smaller litter selection than some other stores
- Pretty Litter
Visit Their Website
Selection: +
Price range: $$ – $$$
Subscription Yes
Autoship option: Yes
Pretty Litter is a great place for buying premium cat litter. This company exclusively sells one type of highly-reviewed litter, which is specially formulated to change color to indicate your cat’s health status. This can be useful to help monitor for medical concerns, like diabetes and urinary tract infections. They are a subscription-based company that only functions on autoship, although the customer has control over how frequently the autoship occurs. They offer a 30-day risk-free guarantee that provides a discount if you aren’t satisfied with the litter. This is a more expensive option, especially in multi-cat homes where you’re keeping up with multiple litter boxes. They regularly offer coupons and deals for toys, treats, and discounts with the purchase of your litter.
Online and in-person shopping options
Same-day pickup and delivery, as well as shipping to home
Autoship is optional and discounted
No subscription required
Carry most major litter brands
Regularly offer discounts
Great customer service
- Online and in-person shopping options
- Same-day pickup and delivery, as well as shipping to home
- Autoship is optional and discounted
- No subscription required
- Carry most major litter brands
- Regularly offer discounts
- Great customer service
Smaller litter selection than some other stores
- Smaller litter selection than some other stores
Selection: +
Price range: $$ – $$$
Subscription Yes
Autoship option: Yes
Pros
Highly-reviewed product and service
Focuses exclusively on a specialty litter
Color-changing litter can indicate medical issues
Customer controls autoship frequency and litter quantity
30-day risk-free guarantee
Regularly offer free add-ons and discounts on orders
Cons
Premium price
Online only
Subscription and autoship only
- PetSmart
Visit Their Website
Selection: +++
Price range: $ – $$$
Subscription No
Autoship option: Yes
PetSmart is a big-box pet store that offers multiple types and brands of cat litter, including most large brands, although they don’t have the largest selection. They don’t require a subscription but do offer a free membership. Autoship is optional and discounted, but PetSmart also offers in-person purchases, shipping, same-day pickup, and same-day delivery. They also offer payment plans to make large purchases more affordable when needed. They regularly offer discounts and coupons to help limit expenses as well. They have been in business since 1986 and have around 1,500 stores.
Highly-reviewed product and service
Focuses exclusively on a specialty litter
Color-changing litter can indicate medical issues
Customer controls autoship frequency and litter quantity
30-day risk-free guarantee
Regularly offer free add-ons and discounts on orders
- Highly-reviewed product and service
- Focuses exclusively on a specialty litter
- Color-changing litter can indicate medical issues
- Customer controls autoship frequency and litter quantity
- 30-day risk-free guarantee
- Regularly offer free add-ons and discounts on orders
Premium price
Online only
Subscription and autoship only
- Premium price
- Online only
- Subscription and autoship only
Pros
Online and in-person shopping options
Carry most major litter brands
Same-day pickup and delivery, as well as shipping to hope
Autoship is optional and discounted
Payment plans are available for many purchases
Regularly offer discounts
Cons
Smaller litter selection than some other stores
- Catit
Visit Their Website
Selection: +
Price range: $ – $$
Subscription No
Autoship option: Yes
Catit is best known for their cat toys, but they do sell wood and pea husk cat litter as well. Their cat litter selection is limited but the products are made from sustainable components that are healthier and safer for everyone. They sell lightweight litter that is vacuum-sealed, limiting the amount of space it takes up. Both types of litter they offer are highly absorbent and a single package is meant to last one cat 30 – 60 days or longer, making these very budget friendly picks for most people. They offer a discounted autoship option but do not require a subscription for purchases.
Online and in-person shopping options
Carry most major litter brands
Same-day pickup and delivery, as well as shipping to hope
Autoship is optional and discounted
Payment plans are available for many purchases
Regularly offer discounts
- Online and in-person shopping options
- Carry most major litter brands
- Same-day pickup and delivery, as well as shipping to hope
- Autoship is optional and discounted
- Payment plans are available for many purchases
- Regularly offer discounts
Selection: +
Price range: $ – $$
Subscription No
Autoship option: Yes
Pros
Sustainable, eco-friendly, lightweight litter
Budget friendly
No subscription required
Autoship is optional and discounted
Cons
Limited product selection
Sustainable, eco-friendly, lightweight litter
Budget friendly
No subscription required
Autoship is optional and discounted
- Sustainable, eco-friendly, lightweight litter
- Budget friendly
- No subscription required
- Autoship is optional and discounted
Limited product selection
- Limited product selection
Selection: ++++
Price range: $ – $$$
Subscription Optional
Autoship option: Yes
- Pet Supplies Plus
Visit Their Website
Selection: ++
Price range: $ – $$$
Subscription No
Autoship option: Yes
Pet Supplies Plus is a chain store that offers a decent selection of cat litter types and brands at reasonable prices. This chain is smaller than many of the other chain store options with just under 600 store locations. They do have online shipping with discounted autoship options, making their products accessible to most people. They offer in-store pickup as well. This company has been in business since 1988, though, and prides itself on good customer service. They regularly offer coupons and sales, making their products even more affordable.
Large selection of cat litter types and brands
Subscription is optional but has benefits
Autoship is optional and discounted
Allows access to multiple vendors in one place
- Large selection of cat litter types and brands
- Subscription is optional but has benefits
- Autoship is optional and discounted
- Allows access to multiple vendors in one place
Selection: ++
Price range: $ – $$$
Subscription No
Autoship option: Yes
Pros
Multiple brands and types of litter available
Autoship is optional and discounted
In-store pickup and shipping available
Regularly offer discounts and coupons
Cons
Smaller litter selection than some other stores
Fewer in-person stores than some other options
Multiple brands and types of litter available
Autoship is optional and discounted
In-store pickup and shipping available
Regularly offer discounts and coupons
- Multiple brands and types of litter available
- Autoship is optional and discounted
- In-store pickup and shipping available
- Regularly offer discounts and coupons
Smaller litter selection than some other stores
Fewer in-person stores than some other options
- Smaller litter selection than some other stores
- Fewer in-person stores than some other options
Buyer’s Guide: Finding The Best Place to Buy Cat Litter
What Makes a Good Place to Buy Cat Litter?
Selection, customer service, and prices are the top things that can make or break a store for any reason. If you’re going to a store that is consistently out of stock of the litter you need, then that store isn’t working for you. It doesn’t make it a “bad” store by any means, but it does mean that it is not the right store to meet your needs.
Good stores should be focused on providing excellent service and working with customers to create the best shopping experience possible. A stressful shopping experience or one that ends with you not getting the product you need isn’t pleasant. If this is the case for you, it might be time to switch shops.
Tips for Buying Cat Litter
Price Shop
You aren’t under any obligation to be committed to a single store! Price shopping for the best deals can help save you a ton of money every year. Some shops may have lower prices at baseline while others may offer coupons and sales throughout the year. Whenever you realize you’re going to need cat litter soon, start price shopping for current and upcoming sales and deals to find the best price.
Even if you keep a clean and tidy litterbox, you probably still find yourself with cat odors and stains around the house – but with the Hepper Advanced Bio-Enzyme Pet Stain & Odor Eliminator Spray, you can permanently remove even the very worst pet stains and smells! Click here to learn more and get yourself a bottle.
At Pet Keen, we’ve admired Hepper for many years, and decided to take a controlling ownership interest so that we could benefit from the outstanding products of this cool cat company!
Find Consistency
Pick a shop that consistently has your products in stock. Obviously, there are things that come up that may lead to something being out of stock on occasion, but it shouldn’t be a consistent issue. There’s no reason you should have to switch to a litter you don’t prefer simply because the store you’re going to never has your preferred product in stock.
Support What You Believe In
Choosing where to spend your money is partly decided by what practices and organizations you choose to support. Some stores may have questionable ethics or employee treatment, and it’s ok to choose to not spend money with those stores. Find shops that support the same ideals that are important to you.
Conclusion
We think that the best overall place to buy cat litter is through Kitty Poo Club. However, if you’re looking to get the most value for your money then we recommend Chewy, which prides itself on having exceptional customer service and offers fair prices. Petco is also a great option as they usually have great deals on cat litter.
If you have a higher budget and are concerned about your cat’s health, then Pretty Litter is a wonderful option. These reviews should help you find a starting point if you’re needing a new place to purchase cat litter.
It can be overwhelming to find the right place to buy cat litter, so we hope that this guide will help with narrowing down the options.
Featured Image Credit: New Africa, Shutterstock
