Monthly subscription boxes make a great holiday or birthday gift for all the cat lovers in your life. Of course, you can treat yourself and your cat to a fun subscription box too! What is the best monthly cat box? The contents of subscription boxes can vary quite a bit, so the answer depends on what you—and your cat—are looking for. Do you want more toys than treats? Are you looking for an affordable option or something fancy? Whatever your needs, the growing popularity of pet subscription boxes means that there’s a box out there for you and your feline friend. These reviews will help you sort out the various choices out there, so you can find the best cat subscription box for any cat on your gift list.
A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites of 2023
Image Product Details
Best Overall
KitNipBox
Free shipping
Themed boxes
Dietary and single cat/multi-cat options
Check Price
Best Value
MeowBox
Free shipping
Handmade toys
Toy and treat or toy only options
Check Price
Premium Choice
BoxCat
Free shipping
Large items included
Toy and treat or toy only options
Check Price
Best for Kittens
Pusheen Box
Free shipping
Pusheen themed items
All boxes have the same price
Check Price
BoxCat Seasonal
Free shipping
Large items included
Treats handmade in the US
Check Price
The 7 Best Cat Subscription Boxes
- KitNipBox Subscription Box – Best Overall
Visit KitNipBox
Subscription: Cancel anytime, free shipping
Features: Toys and treats, different box themes
Options: Single and multi-cat, dietary options
Our choice for the overall best cat subscription box is the KitNipBox Subscription Box. Each box contains a combination of assorted toys and treats. Items are screened for quality and safety. Boxes come in single and multi-cat versions and have options for treats and toys or all toys. The company also donates a portion of proceeds to animal welfare charities. Pros
Dietary and single cat/multi-cat options
Free shipping
Themed boxes
Cons
Small price increase after first box
- MeowBox Subscription Box – Best Value
Check Out MeowBox
Subscription: Cancel anytime, free shipping
Features: Treats sourced from North America, handmade and custom-designed toys
Options: Toys and treats or toys only boxes
The MeowBox Subscription Box is our pick for the best cat subscription box for the money. The company works with small businesses and local artisans, who create unique handmade toys for the boxes. You can specify if you want a box with toys and treats or just toys. The company donates a portion of proceeds to animal charities. Pros
Toy and treat or toy only options
Handmade toys
Free shipping
Cons
Small price increase after first box
- BoxCat Luxury Subscription Box – Premium Choice
Check Out BoxCat Luxury
Subscription: Free shipping
Features: Toys, treats, skincare/gear, 1 large item
Options: Toy and treat or toy only options
The BoxCat Luxury Subscription Box is the premium option from the BoxCat company. Each box comes with treats that are handmade in the US, unique BoxCat-made toys, vegan skincare, or gear (shampoos, collars, etc.), and 1 large item like a bed or scratcher. Pros
Large items included
Toy and treat or toy only options
Free shipping
Cons
Small price increase after 1st box
- Cat Kit by Pusheen Box – Best for Kittens
Check Out Pusheen Box
Subscription: Cancel anytime, free shipping
Features: Pusheen-themed cat toys and accessories
Options: N/A
What could be cuter for a kitten than an adorable Pusheen themed box? The Cat Kit by Pusheen Box comes every 3 months instead of every month, and each box has a unique theme. It includes officially licensed Pusheen themed toys and accessories not available anywhere else. It also includes treats. Pros
Pusheen themed items
Free shipping
All boxes have the same price
Cons
Does not come every month
- BoxCat Seasonal Cat Subscription Box
Check Out BoxCat Seasonal
Subscription: Free shipping
Features: Toys, treats, skincare/gear, 1 or 2 large items
Options: 1 or 2 large item plans
This BoxCat Seasonal Cat Subscription Box is somewhat like the Luxury box subscription. You will get a large Luxury box delivered every 3 months instead of every month. It includes all the items found in the Luxury box, plus you can choose 1 large luxury item or 2 large luxury items per box. Pros
Large items included
Treats handmade in the US
Free shipping
Cons
Small price increase after first box
- BoxCat Monthly Subscription Box
Check Out BoxCat Monthly
Subscription: Free shipping
Features: Toys, treats, skincare/gear
Options: Toy and treat or toy only options
This final BoxCat Monthly Subscription Box is the company’s standard box with no large items included. You will get 1 monthly box with 5 cat items: toys, treats, and skincare or gear. The treats are handmade, and the toys are exclusive to BoxCat. There are treat and toy or toy only options available. Pros
Treats handmade in the US
Free shipping
Cons
Small price increase after first box
- CatLadyBox Subscription Box
Check Out CatLadyBox
Features: Cat toys and cat-themed items
Options: Basic and premium boxes
The CatLadyBox Subscription Box is designed for cat lovers and includes some items for cats as well. You will get cat-themed items like shirts and home décor, plus a selection of cat toys too. All items are vegan-friendly, and each month has a new theme. Pros
Items for people and cats
Cons
No cat treats included
Buyer’s Guide: Choosing the Best Cat Subscription Box Is a cat subscription box the right choice for you? The answer might depend on if you like to carefully pick and choose your cat’s food and toys or if you are up for some surprises.
Tips for Choosing a Subscription Box All subscription box plans will give you an idea of what you’ll be getting, but it’s rare for them to tell you exactly what’s in the box. If you like surprises, subscriptions boxes can be fun. If not, you might be disappointed even with the best cat subscription boxes. Preferences & Special Considerations What about your cat? Cats have their individual preferences when it comes to treats and toys. Even if you shop for every cat item you bring into the house, some will be a hit and some will be ignored. Not everything in a box will likely be a hit with every cat. But that’s a gamble we take even when we pick out their treats and toys ourselves. If your cat has any food allergies or sensitivities, be sure to choose a cat subscription box with an all-toys option, rather than a mix of treats and toys. Other things might be important enough to influence your choice. Are the treats all-natural? Are the toys non-toxic? Do the box companies support small businesses or donate to animal charities? Subscription Box Price & Value Another factor in deciding on any subscription box is whether they’re worth the money. If your cat is picky about treats and toys, a subscription might not be worth it. It’s a good idea to carefully review what goes into boxes at various price points. How many toys and treats will you get each month? Do you get other things besides toys and treats? In other words, are you getting a good value for the money? Most box subscriptions include free shipping. Keep in mind that most tend to discount the 1st box by a few dollars and then raise the price for subsequent boxes. Be sure to review all cost information. Image Credit: kaylaflam, Pixabay Subscription Box Delivery Frequency Many boxes are monthly, but a few come quarterly. If you have a preference one way or the other, be sure to verify if you are getting 12 boxes a year or 4 boxes a year. You should also review the company’s cancellation policy. How far in advance of delivery do you have to cancel? Review the company’s returns policy as well. Will they take back damaged items? How about something your cat just doesn’t like? Subscriptions boxes can be fun for you and your cat. Who doesn’t love to receive and open a new box of goodies every month…human or feline? You may be surprised by what your cat likes or doesn’t like, which can be part of the fun.
Conclusion: Cat Subscription Boxes Ready to choose a subscription box for your cat? While each subscription plan has its unique characteristics, most will provide you with a different selection of toys and treats each month. Which one is right for you and your cat? They all can be fun, but here are a couple of top picks from our reviews. We like the KitNipBox because it’s easy to customize based on your requirements. You can choose single or multi-cat household boxes, and each comes in treats and toys or toys only versions. Each box comes in a different theme, which is fun for you and your cat, making it our overall best cat subscription box. The BoxCat Luxury option is the best cat subscription box for the money and a good choice if you’re looking for something extra. Besides toys and homemade treats, you also get a skincare or gear item, and a large item in each box. It offers more variety than most standard cat subscription boxes.
Monthly subscription boxes make a great holiday or birthday gift for all the cat lovers in your life. Of course, you can treat yourself and your cat to a fun subscription box too!
What is the best monthly cat box? The contents of subscription boxes can vary quite a bit, so the answer depends on what you—and your cat—are looking for.
Do you want more toys than treats? Are you looking for an affordable option or something fancy?
Whatever your needs, the growing popularity of pet subscription boxes means that there’s a box out there for you and your feline friend.
These reviews will help you sort out the various choices out there, so you can find the best cat subscription box for any cat on your gift list.
A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites of 2023
Image Product Details
Best Overall
KitNipBox
Free shipping
Themed boxes
Dietary and single cat/multi-cat options
Check Price
Best Value
MeowBox
Free shipping
Handmade toys
Toy and treat or toy only options
Check Price
Premium Choice
BoxCat
Free shipping
Large items included
Toy and treat or toy only options
Check Price
Best for Kittens
Pusheen Box
Free shipping
Pusheen themed items
All boxes have the same price
Check Price
BoxCat Seasonal
Free shipping
Large items included
Treats handmade in the US
Check Price
The 7 Best Cat Subscription Boxes
- KitNipBox Subscription Box – Best Overall
Visit KitNipBox
Subscription: Cancel anytime, free shipping
Features: Toys and treats, different box themes
Options: Single and multi-cat, dietary options
Our choice for the overall best cat subscription box is the KitNipBox Subscription Box. Each box contains a combination of assorted toys and treats. Items are screened for quality and safety. Boxes come in single and multi-cat versions and have options for treats and toys or all toys. The company also donates a portion of proceeds to animal welfare charities.
Visit KitNipBox
Subscription: Cancel anytime, free shipping
Features: Toys and treats, different box themes
Options: Single and multi-cat, dietary options
Pros
Dietary and single cat/multi-cat options
Free shipping
Themed boxes
Cons
Small price increase after first box
- MeowBox Subscription Box – Best Value
Check Out MeowBox
Subscription: Cancel anytime, free shipping
Features: Treats sourced from North America, handmade and custom-designed toys
Options: Toys and treats or toys only boxes
The MeowBox Subscription Box is our pick for the best cat subscription box for the money. The company works with small businesses and local artisans, who create unique handmade toys for the boxes. You can specify if you want a box with toys and treats or just toys. The company donates a portion of proceeds to animal charities.
Dietary and single cat/multi-cat options
Free shipping
Themed boxes
- Dietary and single cat/multi-cat options
- Free shipping
- Themed boxes
Small price increase after first box
- Small price increase after first box
Check Out MeowBox
Subscription: Cancel anytime, free shipping
Features: Treats sourced from North America, handmade and custom-designed toys
Options: Toys and treats or toys only boxes
Pros
Toy and treat or toy only options
Handmade toys
Free shipping
Cons
Small price increase after first box
- BoxCat Luxury Subscription Box – Premium Choice
Check Out BoxCat Luxury
Subscription: Free shipping
Features: Toys, treats, skincare/gear, 1 large item
Options: Toy and treat or toy only options
The BoxCat Luxury Subscription Box is the premium option from the BoxCat company. Each box comes with treats that are handmade in the US, unique BoxCat-made toys, vegan skincare, or gear (shampoos, collars, etc.), and 1 large item like a bed or scratcher.
Toy and treat or toy only options
Handmade toys
Free shipping
- Toy and treat or toy only options
- Handmade toys
- Free shipping
Check Out BoxCat Luxury
Subscription: Free shipping
Features: Toys, treats, skincare/gear, 1 large item
Options: Toy and treat or toy only options
Pros
Large items included
Toy and treat or toy only options
Free shipping
Cons
Small price increase after 1st box
- Cat Kit by Pusheen Box – Best for Kittens
Check Out Pusheen Box
Subscription: Cancel anytime, free shipping
Features: Pusheen-themed cat toys and accessories
Options: N/A
What could be cuter for a kitten than an adorable Pusheen themed box? The Cat Kit by Pusheen Box comes every 3 months instead of every month, and each box has a unique theme. It includes officially licensed Pusheen themed toys and accessories not available anywhere else. It also includes treats.
Large items included
Toy and treat or toy only options
Free shipping
- Large items included
- Toy and treat or toy only options
- Free shipping
Small price increase after 1st box
- Small price increase after 1st box
Check Out Pusheen Box
Subscription: Cancel anytime, free shipping
Features: Pusheen-themed cat toys and accessories
Options: N/A
Pros
Pusheen themed items
Free shipping
All boxes have the same price
Cons
Does not come every month
- BoxCat Seasonal Cat Subscription Box
Check Out BoxCat Seasonal
Subscription: Free shipping
Features: Toys, treats, skincare/gear, 1 or 2 large items
Options: 1 or 2 large item plans
This BoxCat Seasonal Cat Subscription Box is somewhat like the Luxury box subscription. You will get a large Luxury box delivered every 3 months instead of every month. It includes all the items found in the Luxury box, plus you can choose 1 large luxury item or 2 large luxury items per box.
Pusheen themed items
Free shipping
All boxes have the same price
- Pusheen themed items
- Free shipping
- All boxes have the same price
Does not come every month
- Does not come every month
Check Out BoxCat Seasonal
Subscription: Free shipping
Features: Toys, treats, skincare/gear, 1 or 2 large items
Options: 1 or 2 large item plans
Pros
Large items included
Treats handmade in the US
Free shipping
Cons
Small price increase after first box
- BoxCat Monthly Subscription Box
Check Out BoxCat Monthly
Subscription: Free shipping
Features: Toys, treats, skincare/gear
Options: Toy and treat or toy only options
This final BoxCat Monthly Subscription Box is the company’s standard box with no large items included. You will get 1 monthly box with 5 cat items: toys, treats, and skincare or gear. The treats are handmade, and the toys are exclusive to BoxCat. There are treat and toy or toy only options available.
Large items included
Treats handmade in the US
Free shipping
- Large items included
- Treats handmade in the US
- Free shipping
Check Out BoxCat Monthly
Subscription: Free shipping
Features: Toys, treats, skincare/gear
Options: Toy and treat or toy only options
Pros
Treats handmade in the US
Free shipping
Cons
Small price increase after first box
- CatLadyBox Subscription Box
Check Out CatLadyBox
Features: Cat toys and cat-themed items
Options: Basic and premium boxes
The CatLadyBox Subscription Box is designed for cat lovers and includes some items for cats as well. You will get cat-themed items like shirts and home décor, plus a selection of cat toys too. All items are vegan-friendly, and each month has a new theme.
Treats handmade in the US
Free shipping
- Treats handmade in the US
- Free shipping
Check Out CatLadyBox
Features: Cat toys and cat-themed items
Options: Basic and premium boxes
Pros
Items for people and cats
Cons
No cat treats included
Items for people and cats
- Items for people and cats
No cat treats included
- No cat treats included
Buyer’s Guide: Choosing the Best Cat Subscription Box
Is a cat subscription box the right choice for you? The answer might depend on if you like to carefully pick and choose your cat’s food and toys or if you are up for some surprises.
Tips for Choosing a Subscription Box
All subscription box plans will give you an idea of what you’ll be getting, but it’s rare for them to tell you exactly what’s in the box. If you like surprises, subscriptions boxes can be fun. If not, you might be disappointed even with the best cat subscription boxes.
Preferences & Special Considerations
What about your cat? Cats have their individual preferences when it comes to treats and toys. Even if you shop for every cat item you bring into the house, some will be a hit and some will be ignored.
Not everything in a box will likely be a hit with every cat. But that’s a gamble we take even when we pick out their treats and toys ourselves.
If your cat has any food allergies or sensitivities, be sure to choose a cat subscription box with an all-toys option, rather than a mix of treats and toys.
Other things might be important enough to influence your choice. Are the treats all-natural? Are the toys non-toxic? Do the box companies support small businesses or donate to animal charities?
Subscription Box Price & Value
Another factor in deciding on any subscription box is whether they’re worth the money. If your cat is picky about treats and toys, a subscription might not be worth it.
It’s a good idea to carefully review what goes into boxes at various price points. How many toys and treats will you get each month? Do you get other things besides toys and treats? In other words, are you getting a good value for the money?
Most box subscriptions include free shipping. Keep in mind that most tend to discount the 1st box by a few dollars and then raise the price for subsequent boxes. Be sure to review all cost information.
Subscription Box Delivery Frequency
Many boxes are monthly, but a few come quarterly. If you have a preference one way or the other, be sure to verify if you are getting 12 boxes a year or 4 boxes a year.
You should also review the company’s cancellation policy. How far in advance of delivery do you have to cancel? Review the company’s returns policy as well. Will they take back damaged items? How about something your cat just doesn’t like?
Subscriptions boxes can be fun for you and your cat. Who doesn’t love to receive and open a new box of goodies every month…human or feline? You may be surprised by what your cat likes or doesn’t like, which can be part of the fun.
Conclusion: Cat Subscription Boxes
Ready to choose a subscription box for your cat? While each subscription plan has its unique characteristics, most will provide you with a different selection of toys and treats each month.
Which one is right for you and your cat? They all can be fun, but here are a couple of top picks from our reviews.
We like the KitNipBox because it’s easy to customize based on your requirements. You can choose single or multi-cat household boxes, and each comes in treats and toys or toys only versions. Each box comes in a different theme, which is fun for you and your cat, making it our overall best cat subscription box.
The BoxCat Luxury option is the best cat subscription box for the money and a good choice if you’re looking for something extra. Besides toys and homemade treats, you also get a skincare or gear item, and a large item in each box. It offers more variety than most standard cat subscription boxes.
