With Halloween fast approaching, everyone is looking for costumes, treats, and tricks. That includes your canine companion, who might not be able to trick-or-treat but still wants to have some fun. To help, we looked at bunches of Halloween dog toys to see which ones were the best. If you’re planning to purchase a plaything for your pup, read on to see our reviews of the 12 best Halloween dog toys, including our top pick!
A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites in 2023
Image Product Details
Best Overall
KONG Floppy Knots Pumpkin Squeaky Plush Dog Toy
Durable
Knotted rope for pulling
Very little stuffing inside
Check Price
Best Value
Goody Box Halloween Dog Toys & Treats
Several dog toys in one package
Several high-quality treats
Limited-edition, Chewy exclusive
Check Price
Premium Choice
Frisco Halloween 13 Day Advent Calendar
Wide variety of dog toys
New toy every day for 13 days
A fun activity for you and your dog
Check Price
Best for Puppies
My First Halloween Bone Plush Squeaky Dog
Soft for your puppy’s teeth
Fun to throw and fetch
Great for snuggling
Check Price
Best for Aggressive Chewers
Rantojoy Tough Dog Chew Toy
Food-grade nylon and rubber
Incredibly durable for heavy chewers
Beef flavor embedded in the fibers
Check Price
The 12 Best Halloween Dog Toys
Many Halloween toys for dogs are too easy for them to tear to shreds. KONG, however, knows that dogs play hard, and they designed this fun, spooky toy to deal with heavy play and chewing. Inside the plush body is a durable, knotted rope you and your dog can pull on. Plus, there’s very little stuffing inside, which will make it easier to clean up if your pup manages to tear it open. The Floppy Knots Pumpkin toy is a perfect snuggle toy for napping when they’re done tugging and chewing! Also, it makes a fantastic Halloween decoration for their crate or bed. KONG is the best overall dog toy for Halloween and will provide hours of bone-chilling fun for your dog.
Dog Size: All sizes
Hard or Soft: Soft
Chew, Fetch, or Cuddle: Chew and cuddle
Material: Synthetics, polyester
Check Price on Chewy
Pros
Durable
Knotted rope for pulling
Very little stuffing inside
For small, medium, and large breeds
Cons
The outer body might not last long with big dogs.
If you’re looking for the best value in a Halloween toy for your dog, the Goody Box is an excellent choice. It comes with several Halloween-themed dog toys for different types of play. There are also several Halloween treats your darling doggy will find delectable. This toy box is a Chewy exclusive that only comes around on Halloween and comes in 2 choices. The first is for small and medium dogs, and the second is for medium and large dogs. You’ll be pleased to know that the treats are high-quality, with no fillers, grain, rawhide, or GMOs. They’re also high in protein. You’ll save 30% off the normal retail price by purchasing everything in one spooky package. We think you’ll agree; that’s something to scream about!
Durable
Knotted rope for pulling
Very little stuffing inside
For small, medium, and large breeds
- Durable
- Knotted rope for pulling
- Very little stuffing inside
- For small, medium, and large breeds
The outer body might not last long with big dogs.
- The outer body might not last long with big dogs.
Dog Size: Small/medium, medium/large
Hard or Soft: Both
Chew, Fetch, or Cuddle: All
Material: Polyester, rope
Pros
Several dog toys in one package
Several high-quality treats
Limited-edition, Chewy exclusive
2 sizes to choose from
Cons
You can’t choose which treats or toys are included
Your dog might not like all the treats
Advent calendars aren’t just for Christmas (or just for humans) anymore! This fantastic Halloween dog toy is 13 toys in one, for almost 2 weeks’ worth of fun! Your pup will be pleased with the varied assortment of toys, including rope, plush, and squeakers. You’ll both have fun opening a new gift 13 days in a row, and the excitement in your dog’s eyes will make your day! You can count on all 13 Halloween dog toys made by Frisco to be high-quality, durable, and safe. One thing to note is that the toys aren’t made for big dogs or heavy chewers but for small and medium dogs. It’s also the perfect gift for a friend or family member who’s a dog parent. If you love Christmas advent calendars, this Halloween version will be a true treat!
Several dog toys in one package
Several high-quality treats
Limited-edition, Chewy exclusive
2 sizes to choose from
- Several dog toys in one package
- Several high-quality treats
- Limited-edition, Chewy exclusive
- 2 sizes to choose from
You can’t choose which treats or toys are included
Your dog might not like all the treats
- You can’t choose which treats or toys are included
- Your dog might not like all the treats
Dog Size: Small and medium
Hard or Soft: Both
Chew, Fetch, or Cuddle: All
Material: Polyester, synthetics, rope, cardboard, paper
Pros
Wide variety of dog toys
New toy every day for 13 days
A fun activity for you and your dog
Chewy exclusive product
Cons
Not made for heavy chewers
Choking hazard for large dogs
- Frisco My First Halloween Bone Plush Squeaky Dog Toy – Best for Puppies
Check Latest Price
Dog Size: Small dogs and puppies
Hard or Soft: Soft
Chew, Fetch, or Cuddle: Fetch and cuddle
Material: Synthetics, polyester
Halloween isn’t just for adult dogs; puppies also want in on the action. This super soft squeaky toy from Frisco looks like a bone and has two fun Halloween sayings. For fetch, the Frisco Halloween My First Halloween Bone is the best for puppies since it’s soft enough to throw in the house and does not damage anything. Even better, there’s not one, not two, but three squeakers inside. However, it’s not made for big dogs and aggressive chewers since it’s more of a cuddle and fetch toy. Besides that, it is the perfect git for your puppy and will make their first Halloween the best one ever!
Wide variety of dog toys
New toy every day for 13 days
A fun activity for you and your dog
Chewy exclusive product
- Wide variety of dog toys
- New toy every day for 13 days
- A fun activity for you and your dog
- Chewy exclusive product
Not made for heavy chewers
Choking hazard for large dogs
- Not made for heavy chewers
- Choking hazard for large dogs
Check Latest Price
Dog Size: Small dogs and puppies
Hard or Soft: Soft
Chew, Fetch, or Cuddle: Fetch and cuddle
Material: Synthetics, polyester
Pros
Soft for your puppy’s teeth
Fun to throw and fetch
Great for snuggling
Will keep your puppy company at night
Cons
Not for heavy chewers
- Rantojoy Dog Chew Toy for Large Dogs – Best for Aggressive Chewers
Check Latest Price
Dog Size: Medium and large
Hard or Soft: Hard
Chew, Fetch, or Cuddle: Chew
Material: Nylon, rubber
Ehe Rantojoy Tough Dog Chew Toy is one of the toughest chew toys on the market. It comes with a beef flavor your dog will enjoy and nylon “skulls” on each end to fit the holiday theme. The beef smell is embedded in the fibers of the toy so that it doesn’t fade away but stays strong and smelly (in a good way). The super-strong nylon and durable rubber ensure that your big, strong chewer will have hours and hours of fun chewing, fetching, and playing. The nylon and rubber are both food grade, and you’ll know your precious pup isn’t chewing on something that will upset their tummy. Also, it’s tooth-friendly, so you won’t have to worry that your dog will damage their teeth!
Soft for your puppy’s teeth
Fun to throw and fetch
Great for snuggling
Will keep your puppy company at night
- Soft for your puppy’s teeth
- Fun to throw and fetch
- Great for snuggling
- Will keep your puppy company at night
Not for heavy chewers
- Not for heavy chewers
Dog Size: Medium and large
Hard or Soft: Hard
Chew, Fetch, or Cuddle: Chew
Material: Nylon, rubber
Pros
Food-grade nylon and rubber
Incredibly durable for heavy chewers
Beef flavor embedded in the fibers
Great for fetch, tug of war, and training
Cons
Not meant for small dogs.
- SodaPup Nylon Headstone Chew Dog Toy
Check Latest Price
Dog Size: Large
Hard or Soft: Hard
Chew, Fetch, or Cuddle: Chew and fetch
Material: Nylon, synthetics
The Nylon Headstone chew toy from SodaPup is lots of fun when playing fetch and is durable enough for when your dog is chewing on their own. It’s one of the few dog toys for Halloween we’ve seen that’s dishwasher safe since it’s made with wood composite and nylon. That makes the toy a good one to keep your dog’s teeth in great shape. The manufacturer also claims that it will freshen your pup’s breath, although it’s not flavored in any way. It is meant for heavy chewers and larger breeds. It might be fun for a small or medium dog, but large breeds will enjoy it most. After the holidays are over, the Nylon Headstone also makes a great training tool.
Food-grade nylon and rubber
Incredibly durable for heavy chewers
Beef flavor embedded in the fibers
Great for fetch, tug of war, and training
- Food-grade nylon and rubber
- Incredibly durable for heavy chewers
- Beef flavor embedded in the fibers
- Great for fetch, tug of war, and training
Not meant for small dogs.
- Not meant for small dogs.
Dog Size: Large
Hard or Soft: Hard
Chew, Fetch, or Cuddle: Chew and fetch
Material: Nylon, synthetics
Pros
Made in the USA
Durable
Freshens your dog’s breath
Dishwasher safe
Cons
Made for large dogs only
- ZippyPaws – Halloween Squeakie Buddies
Check Latest Price
Dog Size: Small and medium
Hard or Soft:
Chew, Fetch, or Cuddle:
Material: Synthetics
One of the biggest problems with soft, plush squeaker toys for dogs is that if they break the outer material, the insides are filled with stuffing that can make them choke. This Halloween dog toy, however, has no stuffing inside, making it infinitely safer for your dog. There’s a bat, a Frankenstein monster, and a pumpkin; all three are adorable! ZippyPaws has gone even further by adding their exclusive Blaster squeakers. When the chewing and squeaking are over, they also are soft for cuddling and sleeping. These factors make Halloween Squeaky Buddies perfect for small and medium dogs and puppies. They’re bright, charming, and fun for Halloween.
Made in the USA
Durable
Freshens your dog’s breath
Dishwasher safe
- Made in the USA
- Durable
- Freshens your dog’s breath
- Dishwasher safe
Made for large dogs only
- Made for large dogs only
Dog Size: Small and medium
Hard or Soft:
Chew, Fetch, or Cuddle:
Material: Synthetics
Pros
Better squeakers
No stuffing makes them safer
Fun designs
Package contains 3 toys
Cons
Not made for big dogs and chewers.
Loud squeaker
- Lepawit Halloween Dog Rope Toys
Check Latest Price
Dog Size: Small and medium
Hard or Soft: Soft
Chew, Fetch, or Cuddle: Chew and fetch
Material: Cotton and synthetics
Halloween or not, all dogs love to chew and pull on a rope. Lepawit knows this well and designed their Halloween Dog Rope Toys to be great at both. Your pup can chew until the ghosts come home, or you can have a tug of war on the living room floor! They’re made of double cotton and soft, plush material that is safe for all dogs. Plus, the sinfully fun dog toys are machine washable. When they get a little gross and covered with slobber, just toss them in with the rest of your wash!
Better squeakers
No stuffing makes them safer
Fun designs
Package contains 3 toys
- Better squeakers
- No stuffing makes them safer
- Fun designs
- Package contains 3 toys
Not made for big dogs and chewers.
Loud squeaker
- Not made for big dogs and chewers.
- Loud squeaker
Dog Size: Small and medium
Hard or Soft: Soft
Chew, Fetch, or Cuddle: Chew and fetch
Material: Cotton and synthetics
Pros
Great exercise for dogs
Helps clean your dog’s teeth
Very tough
Three squeakers inside
Cons
Not for big dogs and chewers
Stuffing could be a choking hazard
- Frisco Halloween Glow in the Dark Squeaky Tennis Ball
Check Latest Price
Dog Size: Medium and large
Hard or Soft: Soft
Chew, Fetch, or Cuddle: Chew and fetch
Material: Rubber, synthetics, felt
With the Fetch Squeaky Tennis Ball set from Frisco, you can play fetch with your pet all day long. But wait, it gets even more fun! The tennis balls glow in the dark, so you can play fetch in your yard on Halloween night. All four tennis balls have a different design and are made with a non-abrasive material so that they don’t irritate your dog’s gums. The fun tennis balls also include a squeaker for even more excitement, and they bounce like mad to make playtime even more fun.
Great exercise for dogs
Helps clean your dog’s teeth
Very tough
Three squeakers inside
- Great exercise for dogs
- Helps clean your dog’s teeth
- Very tough
- Three squeakers inside
Not for big dogs and chewers
Stuffing could be a choking hazard
- Not for big dogs and chewers
- Stuffing could be a choking hazard
Dog Size: Medium and large
Hard or Soft: Soft
Chew, Fetch, or Cuddle: Chew and fetch
Material: Rubber, synthetics, felt
Pros
Great exercise for your dog
Set of four balls
Glow in the dark!
Very bouncy
Cons
Not great for idle or older dogs
Not the best for huge dogs
- Frisco Halloween Ghost Plush Squeaky Dog Toy
Check Latest Price
Dog Size: Medium, large and giant
Hard or Soft: Soft
Chew, Fetch, or Cuddle: Fetch and cuddle
Material: Polyester
With 5 squeakers inside, you can rest assured your large dog will have a lot of fun and stay active during the day. Frisco made their Halloween Ghost Plush Squeaky toy durable but soft to satisfy your pup’s urge to chase things and grab them. Even though it is for big dogs, it’s not for heavy, aggressive chewers. If you’re looking for a Halloween toy for your dog that will also be their best buddy, this is a great choice! It’s soft, plush, spooky, and fun and will keep your big hound howling with joy for hours!
Great exercise for your dog
Set of four balls
Glow in the dark!
Very bouncy
- Great exercise for your dog
- Set of four balls
- Glow in the dark!
- Very bouncy
Not great for idle or older dogs
Not the best for huge dogs
- Not great for idle or older dogs
- Not the best for huge dogs
Dog Size: Medium, large and giant
Hard or Soft: Soft
Chew, Fetch, or Cuddle: Fetch and cuddle
Material: Polyester
Pros
Five squeakers!
Extra-large for the largest dogs
Satisfies their grab and chase instincts
Great for nap time
Cons
Not for aggressive chewers
Stuffing inside may come out if the toy breaks
- PUPTECK Cute Dog Rope Toy with Squeaker
Check Latest Price
Dog Size: Small, medium, and large
Hard or Soft: Soft
Chew, Fetch, or Cuddle: Chew
Material: Rope, nylon, synthetics
Rope toys are one of the most beloved by dogs everywhere as most love to pull and tug with their pet parents. Puptech designed their Dog Rope Toy to be able to stand up to rigorous play while also staying soft and pliable. Each package has two rope toys with adorable pumpkin heads to fit the Halloween theme. Inside, there’s a high-quality squeaker to make playtime even more fun. It’s extra loud, though, so keep that in mind. The toys are very durable, but they might not be a good fit for aggressive chewers and extra-large dogs.
Five squeakers!
Extra-large for the largest dogs
Satisfies their grab and chase instincts
Great for nap time
- Five squeakers!
- Extra-large for the largest dogs
- Satisfies their grab and chase instincts
- Great for nap time
Not for aggressive chewers
Stuffing inside may come out if the toy breaks
- Not for aggressive chewers
- Stuffing inside may come out if the toy breaks
Dog Size: Small, medium, and large
Hard or Soft: Soft
Chew, Fetch, or Cuddle: Chew
Material: Rope, nylon, synthetics
Pros
Interactive play
Durable rope “skeleton.”
High-quality squeaker inside
Cons
Stuffing poses a choking hazard
Not great for very large dogs
- Frisco Halloween Foot Latex Squeaky Dog Toy
Check Latest Price
Dog Size: Small and medium
Hard or Soft: Soft
Chew, Fetch, or Cuddle: Chew
Material: Latex
Halloween is the time for gruesome ghosts and horrifying hosts, and this toy from Frisco fits both of those bills perfectly! Made of durable latex for hours of chewing, this ghastly Halloween dog toy looks like a human foot that’s been severed, with blood and bone to increase the realism. One thing that we must mention is that some dogs (not many, but some) will have allergies to latex. If yours does, this toy won’t be a good choice. It might look ghoulish, but it will have your dog howling with fun on Halloween!
Interactive play
Durable rope “skeleton.”
High-quality squeaker inside
- Interactive play
- Durable rope “skeleton.”
- High-quality squeaker inside
Stuffing poses a choking hazard
Not great for very large dogs
- Stuffing poses a choking hazard
- Not great for very large dogs
Dog Size: Small and medium
Hard or Soft: Soft
Chew, Fetch, or Cuddle: Chew
Material: Latex
Pros
Long-term chewing fun
Easy to clean latex
Gruesome fun for your dog
Durable
Cons
Not suitable for large dogs
Some canines have latex allergies
Long-term chewing fun
Easy to clean latex
Gruesome fun for your dog
Durable
- Long-term chewing fun
- Easy to clean latex
- Gruesome fun for your dog
- Durable
Not suitable for large dogs
Some canines have latex allergies
- Not suitable for large dogs
- Some canines have latex allergies
Buyer’s Guide: Finding the Best Halloween Dog Toys
Finding the best Halloween dog toys for your pet can be challenging since so many are on the market. Remember that Halloween dog toys are no different from “regular” ones; they’re just made with a Halloween theme. Below are the attributes any toy you buy for your dog should have, Halloween or not (and some to avoid).
Choose the Correct Size
Choosing the right size toy for your dog is critical. If it’s too big, and it could be too much for your small dog to handle. When it’s too small, and your large dog might choke on it. Most dog toy manufacturers put the size range on their packaging, so be sure to look for it before purchasing.
Avoid Soft, Plush Toys for Aggressive Chewers
Is your dog an aggressive chewer? If yes, you should avoid soft, plush toys. Your pup will likely chew right through the other material and get to the stuffing inside, which could cause a risk of choking. If you want to get your aggressive chewer a soft toy, look for one that doesn’t have stuffing. The ZippyPaws Halloween Squeakie Buddies is one such toy. It’s #7 on today’s list.
Rawhide? No, Thank You.
Rawhide toys are on our list of “no way” toys here at Pet Keen for several reasons. First, they can cause serious intestinal blockages and digestive distress in your dog. They’re also a major choking risk and pose an even bigger risk of contamination after they’ve been chewed on. Rawhide dog toys have also been involved in major recalls over the years, and they can damage your dog’s teeth. The ASPCA and Humane Society both recommend against rawhide.
Choose a Toy That Fits your Dog’s Personality and Energy Level
It’s nice to buy a new toy for your dog, but if they don’t use it, you’re just wasting your money. Knowing your dog is essential when choosing a toy. For example, if your dog is high-energy, a ball, KONG toy, or rope toy would be a good choice. However, a soft chew or plush toy would likely be better for low-energy dogs. The same goes for puzzle toys and toys that make your dog work hard to get to a treat inside. Again, knowing your dog’s personality, energy level, and interest level will help you pick a toy they will genuinely enjoy.
Final Thoughts
Did you enjoy our list of the best Halloween dog toys? We sure hope you did and that your dog will love their new toy! We chose the KONG Halloween Floppy Knots Pumpkin Squeaky Plush Dog Toy as the best overall since it’s tough, cute, and fun! Our best value today is the Goody Box Halloween Dog Toys & Treats, which is loaded with fun. Frisco’s Halloween 13 Day Advent Calendar is our premium choice for Halloween toys for dogs! The best for puppies award went to Frisco again, and the company’s My First Halloween Bone Reversible Plush Squeaky Dog Toy is certain to entertain your little dog. Last on our list was the Rantojoy Tough Dog Chew Toy for Large Dogs. If you have an aggressive chewer, it’s perfect! To you, your family, and all your furry friends, we wish you a safe, fun, and Happy Halloween!
- See also: 10 Halloween Safety Tips for Dogs
Sources
thedodo.com chewy.com elitedaily.com dailypaws.com petco.com
Featured Image Credit: otsphoto, Shutterstock
- thedodo.com
- chewy.com
- elitedaily.com
- dailypaws.com
- petco.com
