What is it about squeakers that makes them so exciting? They’re one of the most popular features in dog toys for a reason—dogs go crazy over them! Whether the toy is a soft plushy or a tough rubber ball, it can be hard to pick a good quality squeaky toy that will stand the test of time and keep your dog’s interest. There isn’t one squeaky toy that is the perfect choice, but in these reviews, we’ll share ten of our favorites and the reasons why we like them.
A Quick Glance At Our Favorites In 2023
Image Product Details
Best Overall
Kong Squeakair Ball Pack
Great for fetch
High-visibility
Available in multi-packs
Check Price
Best Value
Kong Plush Teddy Bear Dog Toy
Removable squeaker
Minimal stuffing
Low price
Check Price
Premium Choice
Godog Furballz Chew Guard Squeaky Plush
Loud squeaker
Soft and cuddly
Machine washable
Check Price
Ethical Pet Puppy Pacifier Latex Dog Toy
Cute Design
Perfect size for puppies
Designed for teething help
Check Price
Gnawsome Squeaker Ball Dog Toy
Long lasting
BPA-free plastic
Great texture
Check Price
The 10 Best Squeaky Dog Toys:
Kong has a reputation for making some of the best dog toys, and the Kong Squeakair Ball Pack is no exception. In fact, we found the Kong Squeakair Ball to be the best overall squeaker toy for dogs. These balls combine a tennis ball with a squeaker toy, bringing some extra noise and fun to one of the most class dog toys out there. These packs come in multiple sizes so that you can play with any breed without trouble. Balls like this are great for fetch and outdoor play, but they can also be used indoors.
Toy Type: Ball
Suitable For: All sizes
Check Price on Chewy
One drawback of the multiple-size approach to this toy is that the balls are made of the same material no matter what size they are. Because of that, some reviewers with small dogs said that their dogs struggled to make the ball squeak loudly. On the other extreme, reviewers with larger dogs said that it didn’t take much time for their dogs to destroy the toy.
Pros
Great for fetch
High-visibility
Available in multi-packs
Multiple sizes available
Cons
Difficult for small dogs to squeak
Large dogs may destroy quickly
If you’re looking for a dog toy that won’t break the bank, we love the Kong Plush Teddy Bear Dog Toy. This toy is available in two sizes, extra small and medium, and features a cuddly plush exterior and a removable squeaker so you can switch off the active, noisy play for something quieter when you need it or replace the squeaker if it breaks. This toy also is free of stuffing, meaning that there is a less possible mess to make—we all know what it’s like to come home and find a plushie ripped apart and a brand new “snowstorm” covering the house!
Great for fetch
High-visibility
Available in multi-packs
Multiple sizes available
- Great for fetch
- High-visibility
- Available in multi-packs
- Multiple sizes available
Difficult for small dogs to squeak
Large dogs may destroy quickly
- Difficult for small dogs to squeak
- Large dogs may destroy quickly
Toy Type: Plush
Suitable For: Small and medium dogs
Because this plush only comes in small and medium sizes, it isn’t suitable for large dogs. It will also wear out quickly if a dog is determined to destroy it, so prepare to replace it regularly.
Pros
Removable squeaker
Minimal stuffing
Low price
Cons
Not suitable for large dogs
Wears out quickly
If you’re willing to pay a little extra for a plush that doesn’t rip on first contact, Godog Furballz Chew Guard Squeaky Plush Dog Toy is a great premium option. This plush is slightly more expensive than most, but it makes up for it with its extra durability. An extra-tough lining layer and a double row of stitching help keep this plush strong through multiple play sessions, and the high reviews show that it does the trick for most dogs. This plush is ball-shaped with a soft and cuddly exterior, cute eyes, and a fun squeaker. It’s great for solo or interactive play. It is also machine washable so that you can keep it clean with minimal trouble.
Removable squeaker
Minimal stuffing
Low price
- Removable squeaker
- Minimal stuffing
- Low price
Not suitable for large dogs
Wears out quickly
- Not suitable for large dogs
- Wears out quickly
Toy Type: Plush
Suitable For: Medium and large dogs
Of course, no plush can last against a determined dog, so don’t expect this one to be any different. Serial destroyers will tear this apart without too much trouble. This plush is also too large for smaller dogs, so it works best for medium and large dogs.
Pros
Double-stitched seams and durable lining
Loud squeaker
Soft and cuddly
Machine washable
Cons
Not indestructible
Too large for smaller dogs
More expensive
Puppies can use just about any dog toy that’s the right size, but the Ethical Pet Puppy Pacifier Latex Dog Toy is a great option. This cute pacifier-shaped toy is the perfect size for most puppies, as well as smaller dogs. With a noisy squeaker, it makes an attractive chew toy that can also be used for fetch. The latex is sized and designed to make it useful for soothing teething puppies, and it contains recycled plastic as well. Because this is made of latex, owners with latex allergies should avoid this product. Although this toy has good reviews overall, it does wear out quickly.
Double-stitched seams and durable lining
Loud squeaker
Soft and cuddly
Machine washable
- Double-stitched seams and durable lining
- Loud squeaker
- Soft and cuddly
- Machine washable
Not indestructible
Too large for smaller dogs
More expensive
- Not indestructible
- Too large for smaller dogs
- More expensive
Toy Type: Chew
Suitable For: Puppies
Pros
Cute Design
Perfect size for puppies
Designed for teething help
Recycled plastic
Cons
Wears out quickly
Contains latex
- See Also: 10 Best Dog Teeth Cleaning Toys in 2022 & Reviews & Top Picks
We loved the design and durability of the Gnawsome Squeaker Ball Dog Toy. The sturdy ball is made from TPR rubber, a strong synthetic rubber that can stand up to a lot of stress without additives like BPA. Its spiky texture makes it feel good on your dog’s mouth and gums and helps increase grip and interest, while the squeaker makes it easy to catch your dog’s attention. Reviewers consistently say that their dog loves this ball. Although this is a fairly durable ball, it’s not indestructible. A few reviewers noticed that the squeaker has a tendency to come out if the ball gets ripped or torn at all, which could be a choking hazard for some dogs.
Cute Design
Perfect size for puppies
Designed for teething help
Recycled plastic
- Cute Design
- Perfect size for puppies
- Designed for teething help
- Recycled plastic
Wears out quickly
Contains latex
- Wears out quickly
- Contains latex
Toy Type: Ball
Suitable For: All Sizes
Pros
Long lasting
BPA-free plastic
Great texture
Cons
Squeaker may fall out
- Frisco Rope with Squeaking Ball Dog Toy
Check Latest Price
Toy Type: Rope toy
Suitable For: Small to large breeds
The Frisco Rope with Squeaking Ball Dog Toy is a great option for dogs who love playing and exercising. This squeaky ball with a rope handle is sized for small, medium, and large dogs. It makes an engaging play toy because of the variety of textures and experiences—between the rough textured rope and the rubbery plastic ball, dogs love playing with this toy, and the squeaker is just the cherry on top. The handle also opens extra play possibilities, making it easy to throw the ball harder or play fetch.
Long lasting
BPA-free plastic
Great texture
- Long lasting
- BPA-free plastic
- Great texture
Squeaker may fall out
- Squeaker may fall out
Check Latest Price
Toy Type: Rope toy
Suitable For: Small to large breeds
Although this toy gets consistently good reviews, some reviewers noted that the rope fell apart quickly and suggested replacing it with a different rope that is sturdier. Reviewers also noted that over time, the squeaker eventually will stop working.
Pros
Extra loud squeaker
Rope handle adds extra play possibilities
Variety of textures for interest
Cons
Rope chews away quickly
Stops squeaking in time
- Kong Tuggerknots Moose Dog Chew Toy
Check Latest Price
Toy Type: Tug Toy
Suitable For: Small to Large breeds
If your dog likes playing tug, you might want to try the Kong Tuggerknots Moose Toy. This toy is made around a rope base with squeakers and stuffing inside, making a game of tug-of-war even more fun! The knotted rope that goes through the middle of the toy gives it a knobby texture that is exciting and fun to play with, and the moose design is soft and cute. The toy comes in two sizes and works for most breeds of dogs. However, this toy does come apart quickly if your dog makes a concerted effort, so it’s not the best choice for destructive dogs.
Extra loud squeaker
Rope handle adds extra play possibilities
Variety of textures for interest
- Extra loud squeaker
- Rope handle adds extra play possibilities
- Variety of textures for interest
Rope chews away quickly
Stops squeaking in time
- Rope chews away quickly
- Stops squeaking in time
Toy Type: Tug Toy
Suitable For: Small to Large breeds
Pros
Exciting squeaking tug toy
Knotted rope interior
Cute design
Cons
Falls apart quickly
- Frisco Flat Plush Squeaking Alligator Dog Toy
Check Latest Price
Toy Type: Flat plush
Suitable For: Any size
The Frisco Flat Plush Squeaking Alligator Dog Toy has a unique design with a flat base and not one but four squeakers to keep your dog interested and excited. The flat base makes it perfect for cuddling on or pawing at. The design is also stuffing-free, making it less messy than many plush toys, while the soft fur keeps the toy cuddly. This toy is best for dogs that aren’t chewers or destructive, as a determined dog can easily tear it apart, but for less destructive dogs, this toy can provide hours of fun. Some reviewers did note that the squeakers stopped over time and that some squeakers were defective, but with four squeakers, the risk of them all breaking is lowered.
Exciting squeaking tug toy
Knotted rope interior
Cute design
- Exciting squeaking tug toy
- Knotted rope interior
- Cute design
Falls apart quickly
- Falls apart quickly
Toy Type: Flat plush
Suitable For: Any size
Pros
Four squeakers
Stuffing free
Flat play design
Cons
Not ideal for chewers
Squeakers stop over time
If your dog loves to fetch and loves noisy toys, consider trying the Nerf Dog Atomic Howler Whistling Flyer Disc Dog Toy. This toy is a ring-shaped flying disk that whistles as it goes through the air and is made of rubber and plastic that make it easy to grip. It’s perfect for long-distance fetch games and has a pretty good range.
Four squeakers
Stuffing free
Flat play design
- Four squeakers
- Stuffing free
- Flat play design
Not ideal for chewers
Squeakers stop over time
- Not ideal for chewers
- Squeakers stop over time
Toy Type: Frisbee
Suitable For: Medium to large breeds
However, not all reviewers were pleased with this toy. Some reviewers found that the frisbee cracked quickly and didn’t hold up to repeated use, while others found that it was too heavy for their dogs to play wth effectively.
Pros
Whistles and squeaks
Easy to grip
Flies far and well
Cons
Heavy
Not ideal for small dogs
Prone to cracking
If toys struggle to hold your dog’s interest, the Playology Squeaky Scented Chew Toy might be a solution. This toy uses “encapsiscent technology” that embeds natural beef scent into the toy, leading to a long-lasting scent that keeps your dog’s attention for longer. The stick is designed for all-weather use and floats and bounces, leading to lots of possibilities for playtime.
Whistles and squeaks
Easy to grip
Flies far and well
- Whistles and squeaks
- Easy to grip
- Flies far and well
Heavy
Not ideal for small dogs
Prone to cracking
- Heavy
- Not ideal for small dogs
- Prone to cracking
Toy Type: Chew
Suitable For: All sizes
Although we love the idea behind this toy, some reviewers note that for a chew toy, it doesn’t hold up very well. Heavy chewers break through this toy quickly, while lighter chewers still see it falling apart over time. Falling apart is also a problem as some reviewers worry the plastic pieces will be a choking hazard for their dog.
Pros
Beef-scented toy
Floats and bounces
Keeps interest longer
Cons
Doesn’t stand up to heavy chewing
Possible choking hazard
Beef-scented toy
Floats and bounces
Keeps interest longer
- Beef-scented toy
- Floats and bounces
- Keeps interest longer
Doesn’t stand up to heavy chewing
Possible choking hazard
- Doesn’t stand up to heavy chewing
- Possible choking hazard
Buyer’s Guide: Selecting The Best Dog Chew Toy
Dog Size
One of the first things to look out for in a dog toy is size. Obviously, dogs come in all different sizes, so picking the right sized toy will make a world of difference. If it is too big, your dog will struggle to lift it and not be able to play with it effectively. If it’s too small, your dog might have a hard time gripping it.
Dog Toy Shape & Texture
Some toys are made of soft and plushy fabric, while others are rubbery or tough. There are also lots of different shapes. Balls are among the most popular and versatile shapes because they are easy to carry and throw. Toys made for chewing are usually long and skinny to fit nicely into your dog’s mouth.
Dog Toy Durability
If you have a chewer, you probably look for durability above anything else. The material you choose also matters when it comes to durability. Fabric toys are generally less durable, even though reinforcements and layered fabric can extend their lifespan. Rubber and plastic toys vary widely in durability, so reading reviews can help. Toys with fewer seams are generally stronger.
Although durability is nice, many dogs can tear apart any toy and even take joy in ripping things open. No toy is indestructible.
Conclusion
As you can see from the reviews, every dog toy has its pros and cons. Overall, we found the best overall toy to be the Kong Squeakair ball because of its versatility and range of sizes. The Kong Plush Teddy Bear is a great low-cost option, while the Godog Furballz Chew Guard Squeaky Plush is an extra-durable plush choice that’s well worth the price. Finally, we found that the Ethical Pet Puppy Pacifier was the perfect size and type for younger puppies. You’ll probably want a variety of toys to let your dog play in different ways, and this list is a great place to start.
