Reviewed & Fact-Checked By
Dr. Nia Perkins
Veterinarian, DVM
Reviewed & Fact-Checked By
Dr. Nia Perkins
Veterinarian, DVM
The information is current and up-to-date in accordance with the latest veterinarian research.
Dogs are such amazing creatures — but what isn’t so amazing is their poop. Did you know that all the dogs in America produce over 10 million tons of poop every year? You have to find the best way to get rid of all the waste that your dog produces every day, but who has time to shop?
That’s where we come in. We reviewed 10 of the best dog waste disposal systems, including those set up in a backyard, waste pails, scoopers, and portable trash bins. We hope that you’ll find the right one for you and your dog’s needs.
A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites of 2023
Image Product Details
Best Overall
Doggie Dooley Waste Disposal System
Acts as a miniature septic tank
Made with galvanized steel with an overflow tube
Polyethylene plastic lid allows for hands-free disposal
Check Price
Best Value
Doggie Doo Drain Pet Waste Removal
Well-priced
Simple to install
No need for poop bags or garbage bins
Check Price
Premium Choice
PawPail Dog & Cat Waste Station
Can be used inside and outside
Activated carbon filter for odors
Comes with environmentally friendly poop bags
Check Price
Litter Genie Cat Litter Disposal System
Five-layer bag locks away odors
Push-n-Lock system seals odors away
Works for cats and dogs
Check Price
PetFusion Portable Pet Waste Disposal
UV and water resistant
Portable with top handle
Charcoal filter to reduce odor
Check Price
The 10 Best Dog Waste Disposal Systems
The best overall dog waste disposal system is the Doggie Dooley Septic Style. This system acts as a miniature septic tank and is made with galvanized steel and placed in the ground, so you know it’s going to last. It’s also hands-free, so you don’t need to worry about getting your hands dirty. It has a lid made with sturdy polyethylene plastic that you press with your foot to open, and it has a large overflow tube. It arrives fully assembled, is environmentally safe and non-toxic, and can hold the waste of four small dogs or two large dogs.
Type: In-ground
Material: Galvanized steel and plastic
Size: 13 x 15 inches
Check Price on Chewy
The issues with this system are that it won’t work if you have very cold winters, and you need to pick up after your dog shortly after they’ve done their business. The system doesn’t work as well with dried-out poop.
Pros
Acts as a miniature septic tank
Made with galvanized steel with an overflow tube
Polyethylene plastic lid allows for hands-free disposal
Non-toxic and safe for the environment
Holds waste of four small or two large dogs
Cons
Won’t work in frigid weather
Only works with fresh waste
The best dog waste disposal system for the money is the Doggie Doo Drain Pet Waste Removal. It works by removing the cap from your septic tank and replacing it with the Doggie Doo Drain, which acts as a funnel. You remove the plug from the drain, dump in the dog poop, rinse with a hose, and replace the lid. This way, there’s no need for special waste cans or poop bags.
Acts as a miniature septic tank
Made with galvanized steel with an overflow tube
Polyethylene plastic lid allows for hands-free disposal
Non-toxic and safe for the environment
Holds waste of four small or two large dogs
- Acts as a miniature septic tank
- Made with galvanized steel with an overflow tube
- Polyethylene plastic lid allows for hands-free disposal
- Non-toxic and safe for the environment
- Holds waste of four small or two large dogs
Won’t work in frigid weather
Only works with fresh waste
- Won’t work in frigid weather
- Only works with fresh waste
Type: Drain for septic tank
Material: Plastic
Size: 12 x 11 x 11 inches
The main flaw with this waste system is that if you live in a location with cold winters, using a hose to rinse the drain is not as doable. Of course, you could bring a bucket of water outside with you.
Pros
Well-priced
Simple to install
No need for poop bags or garbage bins
Environmentally friendly
Cons
Harder to use in cold winters
The PawPail Dog and Cat Waste Station is our premium pick for a dog waste disposal system. It can be used indoors but is durable enough to also be used outdoors. It comes with everything you need for your dog’s poop. It’s a waste pail that comes with a charcoal filter to contain the odor and environmentally friendly poop bags. The bags are stored inside the container, so everything is conveniently close by. It also has a liner basket, so you don’t need a garbage bag.
Well-priced
Simple to install
No need for poop bags or garbage bins
Environmentally friendly
- Well-priced
- Simple to install
- No need for poop bags or garbage bins
- Environmentally friendly
Harder to use in cold winters
- Harder to use in cold winters
Type: Garbage bin
Material: Plastic
Size: 13 x 8 x 18.5 inches
However, this system is quite expensive, and you might find that it doesn’t contain odors very well, particularly on hot days.
Pros
Can be used inside and outside
Activated carbon filter for odors
Comes with environmentally friendly poop bags
Poop bags stored inside the trash can
Liner basket included, so no need for garbage bags
Cons
Expensive
Doesn’t contain odors as well as it should
Don’t let the word “cat” in The Litter Genie Cat Litter Disposal System put you off. If it can contain cat urine and poop smells, it can definitely contain dog poop smells. This system works well to lock stinky odors away with a five-layer bag and an odor barrier. If you also have a cat, this can work for both pets! It has a Push-n-Lock system, and an interior clamp that also helps seal odors away. You just pop it open, drop in the poop, close it up, and you’re done!
Can be used inside and outside
Activated carbon filter for odors
Comes with environmentally friendly poop bags
Poop bags stored inside the trash can
Liner basket included, so no need for garbage bags
- Can be used inside and outside
- Activated carbon filter for odors
- Comes with environmentally friendly poop bags
- Poop bags stored inside the trash can
- Liner basket included, so no need for garbage bags
Expensive
Doesn’t contain odors as well as it should
- Expensive
- Doesn’t contain odors as well as it should
Type: Garbage bin
Material: Plastic
Size: 5 x 8.5 x 22.5 inches
The problems are with the lid. First, it doesn’t always snap in place. Second, while you’re disposing of waste, you need to hold the lid open.
Pros
Five-layer bag locks away odors
Push-n-Lock system seals odors away
Works for cats and dogs
Easy to use
Cons
Lid needs to be held open while in use
Lid doesn’t always snap closed
- PetFusion Portable Outdoor Pet Waste Disposal
Check Latest Price
Type: Garbage can
Material: Plastic
Size: 6 x 10 x 16.7 inches
PetFusion’s Portable Outdoor Pet Waste Disposal is UV and water resistant, so you can store it outside. It’s also made with recycled material. It has an inner bucket with handles that can be easily removed, and it has tabs to lock poop bags in place. It has a handle on top, so it’s portable. It can be locked in place and has a charcoal filter to reduce odor. It also has a poop bag dispenser, which is located on the back of the station.
Five-layer bag locks away odors
Push-n-Lock system seals odors away
Works for cats and dogs
Easy to use
- Five-layer bag locks away odors
- Push-n-Lock system seals odors away
- Works for cats and dogs
- Easy to use
Lid needs to be held open while in use
Lid doesn’t always snap closed
- Lid needs to be held open while in use
- Lid doesn’t always snap closed
Check Latest Price
Type: Garbage can
Material: Plastic
Size: 6 x 10 x 16.7 inches
One issue is that if you have a big dog or more than one, you might find that this garbage can is too small, as you’ll end up cleaning it out frequently. Also, the company doesn’t offer replacement bags.
Pros
UV and water resistant
The removable inner bucket has tabs for locking bags in place
Portable with top handle
Charcoal filter to reduce odor
Poop bag dispenser located on back
Cons
Too small for big dogs
No replacement bags available
- See Also: 10 Best Cat Soap Dispensers: Reviews & Top Picks
The Doggie Dooley In-Ground Dog Waste Disposal System is an in-ground mini septic system. It’s made of durable plastic with a lid that opens when you step on it. It can hold the waste of four small dogs or two large dogs and is eco-friendly because it uses bacteria and enzymes to break down the poop.
UV and water resistant
The removable inner bucket has tabs for locking bags in place
Portable with top handle
Charcoal filter to reduce odor
Poop bag dispenser located on back
- UV and water resistant
- The removable inner bucket has tabs for locking bags in place
- Portable with top handle
- Charcoal filter to reduce odor
- Poop bag dispenser located on back
Too small for big dogs
No replacement bags available
- Too small for big dogs
- No replacement bags available
Type: In-ground
Material: Plastic
Size: 16 x 16 x 7.5 inches
The issue with this disposal system is that since it is only plastic and opens by being stepped on, the entire thing might start to sink into the ground. Additionally, the hinge on the lid can be flimsy and might break after a while.
Pros
Lid opens when stepped on
Holds four small or two large dogs’ waste
Eco-friendly by using bacteria and enzymes to break poop down
Cons
Plastic not as durable as metal
Lid might break after time
The Nature’s Miracle Jaw Dog Poop Scooper is a dog waste disposal system that comes in two sizes, depending on how big your dog’s poop is. If you can avoid touching the poop with your hands through a poop bag, that can make this chore easier. This scooper has an antimicrobial coating and non-stick plastic for easy clean-up. The handle also has a rubber grip for comfort and a spring-action to make it easier to pick up poop.
Lid opens when stepped on
Holds four small or two large dogs’ waste
Eco-friendly by using bacteria and enzymes to break poop down
- Lid opens when stepped on
- Holds four small or two large dogs’ waste
- Eco-friendly by using bacteria and enzymes to break poop down
Plastic not as durable as metal
Lid might break after time
- Plastic not as durable as metal
- Lid might break after time
Type: Scooper
Material: Plastic
Size: Medium or jumbo
However, squeezing the grip to work the scoop might be a challenge if you have any issues with your hands. Also, it can only pick up firmer poop.
Pros
In two sizes
Antimicrobial coating and non-stick plastic
Rubber grip handle for comfort
Spring-action for easy picking up
Cons
Hard to use if you have issues with your hands
Poop must be firm
DDT’s Dog Doo Tube is a great tool for hiding filled poop bags away until they can be thrown out. It comes in three colors — blue, red, and pink — and it has a secure locking lid that will seal away the odors and germs. It has a strong metal ring where a metal carabiner clip is attached. This can be clipped to the leash or your bag. It’s easy to clean and can hold bags for one large dog or a few smaller dogs.
In two sizes
Antimicrobial coating and non-stick plastic
Rubber grip handle for comfort
Spring-action for easy picking up
- In two sizes
- Antimicrobial coating and non-stick plastic
- Rubber grip handle for comfort
- Spring-action for easy picking up
Hard to use if you have issues with your hands
Poop must be firm
- Hard to use if you have issues with your hands
- Poop must be firm
Type: Mini garbage can
Material: Plastic
Size: 3 x 3 x 5 inches
Unfortunately, it’s about the size of a soda can, and if you have a large dog, it might fit one poop, so that’s something to keep in mind. Also, it doesn’t keep the smell in as well as it should.
Pros
Holds filled poop bags until they can be disposed
Comes in three colors
Secure locking lid
Carabiner can attach to leash or bag
Cons
Doesn’t keep the smell in as well as it should
Too small for a large dog
- Doggie Dooley Pet Waste Disposal System
Check Latest Price
Type: In-ground
Material: Plastic
Size: 14 x 14 x 10 inches
The Doggie Dooley Pet Waste Disposal System is an in-ground system that is put into a hole in the ground and opens by being stepped on. It does a good job at keeping odors from escaping, and it’s easy to assemble.
Holds filled poop bags until they can be disposed
Comes in three colors
Secure locking lid
Carabiner can attach to leash or bag
- Holds filled poop bags until they can be disposed
- Comes in three colors
- Secure locking lid
- Carabiner can attach to leash or bag
Doesn’t keep the smell in as well as it should
Too small for a large dog
- Doesn’t keep the smell in as well as it should
- Too small for a large dog
Type: In-ground
Material: Plastic
Size: 14 x 14 x 10 inches
There are a few problems with this system, though. The plastic material that it’s made with is a little flimsy, and the hinge for the lid is prone to breaking. Also, the lid tends to not stay closed at times.
Pros
Step on to open
Prevents odors from escaping
Easy to assemble
Cons
Plastic is a little flimsy
Hinge might break
Lid doesn’t always stay closed
- Arm & Hammer Swivel Bin & Rake Waste Pickup
Check Latest Price
Type: Rake and bin
Material: Plastic
Size: 25 x 13 x 4.5 inches
Arm & Hammer Swivel Bin and Rake Waste Pickup has a rake for sweeping poop into the bin that comes with it. The bin swivels and has a large capacity. The accompanying rake has a handle that can extend to 32 inches, so there’s less need for stooping. It works on all surfaces, like grass and concrete, and it comes with two bags attached to the bin’s sides to keep them in place. This way, you can scoop the poop directly into a bag and not have to touch anything.
Step on to open
Prevents odors from escaping
Easy to assemble
- Step on to open
- Prevents odors from escaping
- Easy to assemble
Plastic is a little flimsy
Hinge might break
Lid doesn’t always stay closed
- Plastic is a little flimsy
- Hinge might break
- Lid doesn’t always stay closed
Type: Rake and bin
Material: Plastic
Size: 25 x 13 x 4.5 inches
The problems here are that the rake is plastic and fairly flimsy. The bin can also be bigger. It might work if you have a small dog, but you should look for something else if you have a large breed. Also, you’ll need to buy Arm & Hammer’s bags as replacements.
Pros
Large-capacity bin swivels
Rake’s handle extends to 32 inches
Works on grass and concrete
Poop bags attach to inside of bin
Cons
Rake is a little flimsy
Need to buy replacement bags
Bin on the small side
Large-capacity bin swivels
Rake’s handle extends to 32 inches
Works on grass and concrete
Poop bags attach to inside of bin
- Large-capacity bin swivels
- Rake’s handle extends to 32 inches
- Works on grass and concrete
- Poop bags attach to inside of bin
Rake is a little flimsy
Need to buy replacement bags
Bin on the small side
- Rake is a little flimsy
- Need to buy replacement bags
- Bin on the small side
Buyer’s Guide: Selecting The Best Dog Waste Disposal System
Hopefully, reading through these reviews has given you a better idea of what kind of waste disposal system you’re looking for. But before you decide anything, check out this buyer’s guide, as we go over a few more points that could impact your decision.
Type
There are several different ways to dispose of dog poop: in-ground, scooper, and bin. A scooper is meant to make it easier for you, so you can avoid stooping over or handling poop with a poop bag on your hand. A waste bin is meant to keep odors from escaping, so you’ll want to ensure that it has a filter and a good seal.
In-Ground
An in-ground system acts as a mini septic tank. You will need to dig a deep hole, so you might want to use a post-hole digger. Once the hole has been dug, you’ll need enzyme tablets that will break down the poop. Make sure the system comes with enzyme tablets, and if not, order them separately because the system won’t work without them. Keep in mind that if you live somewhere with cold winters, it will stop working during those months.
Poop Is Poop
It doesn’t matter if the waste disposal system is meant for cats or dogs. Poop is poop, so you don’t have to limit your search to only systems designed for dogs. Some cat waste systems are excellent at keeping strong odors away, so be sure to look at these if you’re not satisfied with waste bin systems for dogs.
Even if you keep a clean and tidy litterbox, you probably still find yourself with cat odors and stains around the house – but with the Hepper Advanced Bio-Enzyme Pet Stain & Odor Eliminator Spray, you can permanently remove even the very worst pet stains and smells! Click here to learn more and get yourself a bottle.
At Pet Keen, we’ve admired Hepper for many years, and decided to take a controlling ownership interest so that we could benefit from the outstanding products of this cool cat company!
Size
Don’t forget that the bigger the dog, the bigger the system needs to be, especially if you have multiple dogs. If you decide on an in-ground system, you might need to invest in several of these disposal systems if your dog has enormous poops. Likewise with any bins or scoops. The larger the poop, the larger your equipment needs to be.
- See Also: 8 Best Washable Dog Pee Pads – Reviews & Top Picks
Conclusion
Our overall favorite waste disposal system is the Doggie Dooley Septic Style. It’s made with galvanized steel, so you know that it’s sturdy and will last for ages. The Doggie Doo Drain Pet Waste Removal system actually replaces the lid of your septic tank. It creates a funnel so you can directly dispose of the poop, and all for a good price. Finally, the PawPail Dog and Cat Waste Station is our pick for premium choice because it can be used inside and outside, and it includes a convenient poop bag dispenser.
We hope all these reviews have helped you narrow down your search and you have found something that will work best for you. Poop is not the most fun part of dog ownership, but some of these products might make this chore a little easier.
Featured Image Credit: Miriam Doerr Martin Frommherz, Shutterstock
