Reviewed & Fact-Checked By
Dr. Paola Cuevas
Veterinarian, MVZ
Reviewed & Fact-Checked By
Dr. Paola Cuevas
Veterinarian, MVZ
The information is current and up-to-date in accordance with the latest veterinarian research.
Providing nutritious food and treats for your canine is vital for maintaining a healthy lifestyle. High-quality meals were once a niche market, but now, premium brand companies enjoy record sales. Although high-end pet food is typically produced with fewer fillers and preservatives than discount brands, some products are too expensive for average consumers.
If you purchase a quality mid-range pet food and supplement it with a dog food topper, you can boost the nutritional value without spending a fortune. Toppers can also be substituted for treats, and some brands are healthier than low-priced dog snacks. Manufacturers produce several dog food toppers, but we found the best wet, freeze-dried, and dry products for your pup. Our reviews detail the products’ high points and disadvantages, and we included a buyer’s guide to help you choose the ideal brand.
A Glance at Our Favorite Choices in 2023
Image Product Details
Best Overall
Instinct Raw Boost Mixers
Made with cage-free chicken
No wheat, soy, artificial flavors, or colors
Freeze-drying process retains essential nutrients
Check Price
Best Value
Cesar Simply Crafted Variety Pack
Free of chemicals, fillers, artificial colors, and artificial flavors.
Made with chicken, vegetables, and fruit
Low in fat and high in moisture
Check Price
Premium Choice
The Honest Kitchen Bone Broth Dog Food Topper
Made with only seven natural ingredients
Encourages dogs to eat dry kibble
Beef comes from ranch-based cattle
Click to Save 30% Use code PETKEEN30
Stella & Chewy’s Super Beef Meal Mixers
High in protein from grass-fed cattle
Free of gluten, fillers, and preservatives
Made with 100% organic fruit and vegetables
Check Price
Wellness CORE Bowl Boosters Bare
High in protein and low in fat
Only four ingredients
Made without fillers, artificial colors, or preservatives
Check Price
The 10 Best Dog Food Toppers
Whether your pet needs a boost of meaty flavor added to its ordinary kibble or added fiber to improve digestion, you can try Instinct Freeze Dried Raw Boost Mixers. It won our prize for the best overall dog food topper. Instinct Freeze-Dried the raw material to lock in nutrients, unlike competitors’ dried products baked in high-temperature ovens.
Topper Type: Freeze-dried raw
Crude Protein: 36%
Crude Fat: 30%
Calories: 4,555 kilocalories/kilogram
Check Price on Chewy
Some of Raw Boost’s ingredients include cage-free chicken, chicken heart, chicken liver, dried pumpkin, sweet potato, pumpkin seeds, and apple cider vinegar. It’s grain-free and does not contain preservatives, soy, or artificial chemicals. The manufacturer claims that adding its topper to dog food can improve digestion, maintain weight, and give your dog more vitality and energy. Although we love the high-protein topper, some customers mentioned that the product’s texture is so delicate it can crumble if it’s not handled with care.
Pros
Made with cage-free chicken
No wheat, soy, artificial flavors, or colors
Freeze-drying process retains essential nutrients
Supplemented with natural probiotics
Cons
Delicate texture can crumble
Dog food toppers are typically more expensive than ordinary dog treats, but we picked Cesar Simply Crafted Variety Pack as the best topper for the money. Although it’s not as densely packed with protein and other nutrients as our previous pick, Cesar’s ingredients are free of unnecessary filler, artificial flavors, colors, and preservatives. We were impressed that the two chicken variety toppers are solely composed of chicken, fruit, and vegetables. Each portion contains 0.2% crude fat, 15% crude protein, 1.5% crude fiber, and 81% moisture.
Made with cage-free chicken
No wheat, soy, artificial flavors, or colors
Freeze-drying process retains essential nutrients
Supplemented with natural probiotics
- Made with cage-free chicken
- No wheat, soy, artificial flavors, or colors
- Freeze-drying process retains essential nutrients
- Supplemented with natural probiotics
Delicate texture can crumble
- Delicate texture can crumble
Topper Type: Wet
Crude Protein: 15%
Crude Fat: 0.2%
Calories: 785 kilocalories/kilogram
Cesar’s toppers provide a higher moisture content than many wet food meals, making them a great choice for dogs at risk of dehydration. Although the Simply Crafted pouches are ideal for small dogs and toy breeds, the portions are less affordable for large breed owners.
Pros
Free of chemicals, fillers, artificial colors, and artificial flavors.
Made with chicken, vegetables, and fruit
Low in fat and high in moisture
Variety pack provides two healthy toppers
Cons
Small portions
- The Honest Kitchen Bone Broth Beef Stew Dog Food Topper – Premium Choice
Check Price on The Honest Kitchen Check Price on Chewy
Use code PETKEEN30 to SAVE 30% on your first order over $30 on thehonestkitchen.com
Topper Type: Bone broth
Crude Protein: 5%
Crude Fat: 2.5%
Calories: 684 kilocalories/kilogram
If you’ve tried several brands of premium kibble that your picky dog refused, you can use The Honest Kitchen Bone Broth POUR OVERS to liven up bland, dry food. The manufacturer uses ranch-based beef and carrots in its bone broth and makes the Beef Stew in a human-grade facility. The only ingredients are beef, bone broth, carrots, butternut squash, tapioca, thyme, and sage. The Honest Kitchen does not use chemicals to preserve its product or artificial flavors and colors.
Free of chemicals, fillers, artificial colors, and artificial flavors.
Made with chicken, vegetables, and fruit
Low in fat and high in moisture
Variety pack provides two healthy toppers
- Free of chemicals, fillers, artificial colors, and artificial flavors.
- Made with chicken, vegetables, and fruit
- Low in fat and high in moisture
- Variety pack provides two healthy toppers
Small portions
- Small portions
Check Price on The Honest Kitchen Check Price on Chewy
Check Price on The Honest Kitchen
- Use code PETKEEN30 to SAVE 30% on your first order over $30 on thehonestkitchen.com
The broth is our premium pick, but it will last longer when you have a medium or small breed. It’s not as thick as stew gravy for human meals, but it looks more like homemade gravy than most wet pet food. The most common complaint about the broth is the packaging. Some customers had problems opening the package and sealing it to preserve the remainder.
Pros
Made with only seven natural ingredients
Encourages dogs to eat dry kibble
Beef comes from ranch-based cattle
Cons
Package is difficult to open
Several treats and raw food toppers are not suitable for young pups, but Stella and Chewy’s Super Beef Meal Mixers is safe for puppies and adults. Meal Mixer is high in protein and loaded with vitamins, antioxidants, and probiotics and free of gluten, preservatives, colors, and grains. You can serve the mixer as a meal replacement or supplement to dog food.
Made with only seven natural ingredients
Encourages dogs to eat dry kibble
Beef comes from ranch-based cattle
- Made with only seven natural ingredients
- Encourages dogs to eat dry kibble
- Beef comes from ranch-based cattle
Package is difficult to open
- Package is difficult to open
Topper Type: Freeze-dried raw
Crude Protein: 44%
Crude Fat: 35%
Calories: 4,940 kilocalories/kilogram
Some of the ingredients include beef, beef heart, beef kidney, cranberries, beets, carrots, spinach, and broccoli. The fruits and vegetables are 100% organic, and the beef comes from grass-fed cattle. Since it has 44% crude protein and 35% crude fat, we suggest reducing the amount of kibble when adding the topper. Our only complaints about the Beef Meal are the pieces may be too large for tiny pups, and it’s a little expensive.
Pros
High in protein from grass-fed cattle
Free of gluten, fillers, and preservatives
Made with 100% organic fruit and vegetables
Supplemented with antioxidants, vitamins, and probiotics
Cons
Pieces are too large for some pups
Expensive
Whether you want to gradually introduce your pet to raw food or need a high-protein boost added to kibble, you can try Wellness CORE Bowl Boosters Bare. It has a higher crude protein content than any topper we reviewed, and it’s made without preservatives, fillers, or artificial colors. Its only ingredients are turkey, mixed tocopherols, green tea extract, and rosemary extract. Although Core is a healthy addition to any meal, the manufacturer recommends only using it as a supplement rather than a meal replacement.
High in protein from grass-fed cattle
Free of gluten, fillers, and preservatives
Made with 100% organic fruit and vegetables
Supplemented with antioxidants, vitamins, and probiotics
- High in protein from grass-fed cattle
- Free of gluten, fillers, and preservatives
- Made with 100% organic fruit and vegetables
- Supplemented with antioxidants, vitamins, and probiotics
Pieces are too large for some pups
Expensive
- Pieces are too large for some pups
- Expensive
Topper Type: Freeze-dried raw
Crude Protein: 70%
Crude Fat: 10%
Calories: 3,695 kilocalories/kilogram
Bowl Boosters is a top seller, and pet parents appreciate the limited-ingredient recipe. However, some dogs and their owners are turned off by the topper’s pungent aroma. Other reviewers mentioned that the portion size is inconsistent.
Pros
High in protein and low in fat
Only four ingredients
Made without fillers, artificial colors, or preservatives
Cons
Strong smelling
Morsel size is inconsistent
Vital Essentials Beef Freeze-Dried Raw topper is the only brand we reviewed that makes a product recommended for dogs and cats. The protein-rich topper is made with 100% USA beef, organs, bones, vitamins, and amino acids. It does not contain artificial preservatives, fillers, gluten, or grains. Vital Essentials can be added to dry food, wet meals, or used to prepare your dog for a raw diet.
High in protein and low in fat
Only four ingredients
Made without fillers, artificial colors, or preservatives
- High in protein and low in fat
- Only four ingredients
- Made without fillers, artificial colors, or preservatives
Strong smelling
Morsel size is inconsistent
- Strong smelling
- Morsel size is inconsistent
Topper Type: Freeze-Dried Raw
Crude Protein: 40%
Crude Fat: 23%
Calories: 4,500 kilocalories/kilogram
Although cats and dogs have similar nutritional requirements, cats require more protein in their diets than dogs. It’s strange that a company makes a cat/dog topper, but cats seem to like it. While 40% crude protein is not too high when used as a dog food topper, it may be too rich for some dogs with medical conditions that require a low-protein or low-fat diet. Vital Essentials is a nutrient-dense product, but it has problems with consistency. Many pet parents complained that the freeze-dried bits were too powdery or chunky. Some mentioned that their pups disliked the flavor.
Pros
Made with 100% U.S. beef
Free of fillers, gluten, grains
Cons
Expensive
Inconsistent texture
Some dogs disliked the flavor
Tylee’s Freeze-Dried Mixers for Dogs is made with wild-caught salmon and cage-free chicken. It does not include corn, soy, wheat, or preservatives. Cage-free chicken and wild-caught salmon are the primary protein sources, and it’s loaded with nutritious vegetables, fruit, and superfoods, including organic strawberries, organic pumpkin, organic broccoli, chia seeds, and flaxseeds.
Made with 100% U.S. beef
Free of fillers, gluten, grains
- Made with 100% U.S. beef
- Free of fillers, gluten, grains
Expensive
Inconsistent texture
Some dogs disliked the flavor
- Expensive
- Inconsistent texture
- Some dogs disliked the flavor
Topper Type: Freeze-dried raw
Crude Protein: 45%
Crude Fat: 30%
Calories: 4,745 kilocalories/kilogram
The freeze-dried bites can be added to meals dry or rehydrated with water for wet food. Although the mixer can be served with water, you have to wait several minutes for the topper to soften. Customers were happy with Tylee’s, and dogs seemed to love the flavor, but some complained that the price was too high for the meager 8-ounce bag.
Pros
Free of fillers, corn, soy, and preservatives
Includes organic fruit and vegetables
Made with wild-caught salmon and cage-free chicken
Cons
Takes several minutes to hydrate morsels
Expensive
Blue Buffalo was one of the first producers to promote high-quality dog food, and their Wilderness Trail Topper Wild Cuts Variety Pack gives canines the option of feasting on Chunky Chicken or Beef Bites. Wild Cuts is excellent for dogs on a grain-free regimen, and it’s free of animal by-products, artificial flavors, and preservatives. It’s not as nutritionally balanced as other topper products, but wet meals are typically not as nutrient-dense as freeze-dried treats.
Free of fillers, corn, soy, and preservatives
Includes organic fruit and vegetables
Made with wild-caught salmon and cage-free chicken
- Free of fillers, corn, soy, and preservatives
- Includes organic fruit and vegetables
- Made with wild-caught salmon and cage-free chicken
Takes several minutes to hydrate morsels
Expensive
- Takes several minutes to hydrate morsels
- Expensive
Topper Type: Wet
Crude Protein: 8%
Crude Fat: 2.5 %
Calories: 920 kilocalories/kilogram
Some dogs enjoy Wild Cuts, but many pet parents complained that their dogs did not like the food’s flavor, and others mentioned the topper gave their pets indigestion.
Pros
Ideal for pups allergic to grains
Does not include by-products, preservatives, or artificial flavors
Features chunky chicken and beef bites toppers
Cons
Not as nutritionally balanced as competitors
Gives some pups upset stomachs
Some dogs dislike the flavor
Tiki Dog Aloha Petites Flavor Booster Lamb in Bisque is a wet food topper made with lamb, lamb broth, sunflower oil, and other natural ingredients. It’s made to promote a shiny coat and healthy skin, and the topper does not contain artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives. It can be served as a moisture-rich topping or as a savory treat.
Ideal for pups allergic to grains
Does not include by-products, preservatives, or artificial flavors
Features chunky chicken and beef bites toppers
- Ideal for pups allergic to grains
- Does not include by-products, preservatives, or artificial flavors
- Features chunky chicken and beef bites toppers
Not as nutritionally balanced as competitors
Gives some pups upset stomachs
Some dogs dislike the flavor
- Not as nutritionally balanced as competitors
- Gives some pups upset stomachs
- Some dogs dislike the flavor
Topper Type: Wet
Crude Protein: 4%
Crude Fat: 2%
Calories: 695 kilocalories/kilogram
Although the broth adds flavor and nutrients to bland food, it’s not as healthy as its competitors. Most customers were happy with the topper as it convinced their pets to consume kibble. However, some dog lovers complained that too much of the product is liquid without much meat. Tiki Dog uses only eight ingredients in its recipe, but some U.S. consumers may be hesitant to buy pet food from Thailand.
Pros
Lamb is the first ingredient
Contains no artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives
Cons
Too much liquid
Low in protein and calories
Brutus Bone Broth Beef Flavor is an all-natural topper that can be added to wet or dry food or frozen for a chilly treat. It’s made with human-grade ingredients such as beef broth, vegetable broth, and turmeric. The recipe does not include GMOs, dairy, soy, and gluten. It’s an excellent choice for overweight dogs that need toppers low in calories and fat.
Lamb is the first ingredient
Contains no artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives
- Lamb is the first ingredient
- Contains no artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives
Too much liquid
Low in protein and calories
- Too much liquid
- Low in protein and calories
Topper Type: Bone broth
Crude Protein: 5.0%
Crude Fat: 0.0%
Calories: 51 kilocalories/kilogram
Brutus broth can convince dogs to eat kibble, but it does not provide much of a nutritional boost. It’s low in protein and seems mostly composed of water when you see it has 97% moisture. The primary issues with the topper are the high price and the reluctance of some dogs to eat their food once it’s covered in broth. Some pups dislike the smell and flavor.
Pros
Can be frozen for use as a treat
Glucosamine and chondroitin for healthy joints
Cons
Low in protein and calories
Expensive
Some dogs dislike the flavor and smell
Can be frozen for use as a treat
Glucosamine and chondroitin for healthy joints
- Can be frozen for use as a treat
- Glucosamine and chondroitin for healthy joints
Low in protein and calories
Expensive
Some dogs dislike the flavor and smell
- Low in protein and calories
- Expensive
- Some dogs dislike the flavor and smell
Buyer’s Guide: How to Choose the Best Dog Food Topper
You have several options when choosing a dog food topper, but which one is best for your pup? Before picking a product, you can examine a few factors that may influence your decision.
Options for Serving Toppers
Premium dog food is typically more nutritious than discount brands. If you serve high-quality food to your pet, you might not need a dog food topper. A topper can add unnecessary calories to an already balanced diet depending on the type you use. However, toppers are helpful in other ways. You may have purchased top-of-the-line dog food only to find that your dog hates the flavor and rejects it.
Throwing away a $100 bag of food is irritating and costly, but you can add a topper to see if it livens up the bland food. Bone broth and wet toppers are not as nutrient-dense as freeze-dried products, and they’re the ideal toppers to add if the kibble provides enough protein, fiber, and nutrients.
Adding a topper can also make your dog’s meal more digestible. Dry kibble it’s not as easy for dogs to digest as wet meals. A wet or raw topper can improve your dog’s digestion and make the meal more appealing to your pup.
Freeze-Dried Products
If you want to increase the nutritional value of dog food, a freeze-dried topper is an ideal choice. Raw meat toppers are packed with high-quality protein, fat, minerals, vitamins, and probiotics. Some brands are higher in protein than most premium dog food, and topper manufacturers usually recommend reducing the amount of kibble when you add a topper. This prevents you from overfeeding your dog, and most of the time, you only have to reduce the kibble by ¼ cup or less.
Unlike wet toppers or broth, you have to be more careful handling freeze-dried toppers. They’re made with raw meats, and you should always wash your hands thoroughly after serving them. Raw pellets can contain pathogens that give you a foodborne illness if you eat something after touching the product.
Wet Toppers
If you have a senior dog prone to urinary infections or one who has problems drinking enough water, we suggest using a wet topper or bone broth. Wet products have high levels of moisture that can prevent dehydration, and they’re not as nutrient-dense as freeze-dried toppers.
Adult canines typically require fewer calories than younger pups, and a wet topper will not increase the values to unhealthy levels. In comparison, a freeze-dried product may be too rich for an older dog or less active dog if it is too high in fat content.
Bone Broths
If you examine the broths we reviewed, you’ll notice they have fewer calories, protein, and fat than the other types. When you’re trying to get your pet to eat expensive kibble, a bone broth can improve the flavor and moisture content without altering the nutritional content. They will not give your dog a huge boost of additional protein, but the broths add hydration and make the food more flavorful saving you from tossing a pricey bag of kibble.
Veterinary Advice
Although toppers come in small portions, it’s wise to speak with a veterinarian before serving new products to your dog. The doctor may suggest using a smaller portion than the manufacturer recommends. Obesity is a significant problem for humans and pets. At least 25% to 30% of U.S. dogs are overweight, and you have to be careful how much extra you add to a premium dog food.
Conclusion
Our reviews examined the best dog food toppers on the market, and we hope you’ve found the right product for your best friend. We were impressed with several toppers, but our overall favorite was Instinct Freeze-Dried Raw Boost Mixers. It’s protein-dense and made with cage-free chicken and wholesome vegetables like sweet potato and pumpkin. The grain-free recipe is ideal for canines with allergies. Our best value pick was Cesar Simply Crafted Variety Pack. The limited-ingredient recipes are free of fillers and preservatives, and the two chicken meals add moisture and flavor to bland kibble.
Featured Image Credit: Anastasiya Tsiasemnikava, Shutterstock
