If you’re reading this, you probably have a dog that enjoys a good barking session — and it’s probably irritating you and your neighbors. Dogs bark for many reasons, but being territorial is usually one of the main motivations, and you need to figure out how to deal with it. But what is the best way? That’s what we’re here for. We developed reviews of the 10 best barking deterrents and included a buyer’s guide that will hopefully make your decision easier. We want you to have a happy family, happy neighbors, and of course, a happy dog.
A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites in 2023
Image Product Details
Best Overall
Petdiary T720 Dog Training Collar
3,000 feet range
Fits up to a 22-inch neck
Four deterrent options: vibration, shock, beep, and LED
Check Price
Best Value
PATPET P301 Remote Dog Training Collar
980-foot range and waterproof
Gives you a warning if the levels are too high
Remote and collar hold about an 11-day charge
Check Price
Premium Choice
Educator E-Collar Technologies Dog Training Collar
Tone and tapping vibration stimulation
Tracking light for night and is waterproof
“Lock and set” levels 1–100 and boost levels 1–60
Check Price
PATPET P-C80 Lightweight Remote Dog Training Collar
Recharges quickly
Works for up to two dogs
16 levels of stimulation in sounds, vibrations, or shocks
Check Price
Company of Animals Pet Corrector Spray
Safe, harmless, and painless
Used along with a reward-based system
Hissing sound using air to startle a barking dog
Check Price
The 10 Best Dog Barking Deterrents
The best overall dog barking deterrent is the well-priced Petdiary T720 Dog Training Collar. It has four different options to help stop your dog from barking: vibration, shock, beep, and an LED light. This gives you the option to turn off the features that you don’t want to use and find the one that will work with your dog. It works remotely, giving your dog a 3,000 feet range, and will fit dogs up to 110 pounds and up to a 22-inch neck. It comes with a chargeable collar (which can last 180 days on a full charge) and a transmitter (which lasts 40 days). If you have another two collars, the system can work for three dogs at once, and the collar is waterproof and reflective.
Type: Collar
Size: Up to 22-inch neck
Weight: Dogs up to 110 lbs.
Range: 3,000 feet
Method: Sound, shock, vibration, or LED
Check Price on Chewy
The flaws of this collar are that for some people, the instructions aren’t the most user-friendly, and for others, the collar might stop working after a while.
Pros
Well-priced
Four deterrent options: vibration, shock, beep, and LED
3,000 feet range
Fits up to a 22-inch neck
Chargeable collar lasts 180 days and the transmitter lasts 40 days
Waterproof and reflective
Works with three dogs at once
Cons
Instructions are not always easy to follow
Might stop working
The best dog barking deterrent for the money is the PATPET Remote Dog Training Collar that comes with a collar and remote that holds about an 11-day charge. You can choose from eight vibration levels, 16 shock levels, or loud beeps to deter your dog from barking, but it also gives you a warning if the levels are too high for your pup. The range of the collar is about 980 feet, and it’s waterproof.
Well-priced
Four deterrent options: vibration, shock, beep, and LED
3,000 feet range
Fits up to a 22-inch neck
Chargeable collar lasts 180 days and the transmitter lasts 40 days
Waterproof and reflective
Works with three dogs at once
- Well-priced
- Four deterrent options: vibration, shock, beep, and LED
- 3,000 feet range
- Fits up to a 22-inch neck
- Chargeable collar lasts 180 days and the transmitter lasts 40 days
- Waterproof and reflective
- Works with three dogs at once
Instructions are not always easy to follow
Might stop working
- Instructions are not always easy to follow
- Might stop working
Type: Collar
Size: 8-25 inches neck
Weight: Dogs 20-90 lbs.
Range: 984 feet
Method: Sound, vibration, or shock
However, the collar tends to break, and the battery life isn’t always as good as what the company advertises.
Pros
Inexpensive
Remote and collar hold about an 11-day charge
Eight vibration levels, 16 shock levels, or loud beeps
Gives you a warning if the levels are too high
980-foot range and waterproof
Cons
Collar might break
Battery might not last as long as you want
The Educator E-Collar Technologies Dog Training Collar is the premium choice because it uses low-level electronic stimulation to humanely train your dog. It also has “lock and set” levels from 1 to 100 and a way to set boost levels from 1 to 60. It gives quite a large range for your pup for up to 3,960 feet and uses tones and tapping vibration stimulation. It has a tracking light for the night, is waterproof, and works with up to two dogs. The battery life for the collar and remote should last about 24 to 72 hours.
Inexpensive
Remote and collar hold about an 11-day charge
Eight vibration levels, 16 shock levels, or loud beeps
Gives you a warning if the levels are too high
980-foot range and waterproof
- Inexpensive
- Remote and collar hold about an 11-day charge
- Eight vibration levels, 16 shock levels, or loud beeps
- Gives you a warning if the levels are too high
- 980-foot range and waterproof
Collar might break
Battery might not last as long as you want
- Collar might break
- Battery might not last as long as you want
Type: Collar
Size: Up to 30-inch neck
Weight: Dogs over 5 lbs.
Range: 3,960 feet
Method: Tone, shock, or vibration
The main disadvantages of this system are that it is quite expensive and it is a training system, not just a bark deterrent. It may take a while for you and your dog to figure things out.
Pros
Humane use of low-level electronic stimulation for training
“Lock and set” levels 1–100 and boost levels 1–60
Tone and tapping vibration stimulation
Tracking light for night and is waterproof
Can be used for up to two dogs
Cons
Expensive
Training system that takes time
PATPET’s P-C80 Lightweight Remote Dog Training Collar gives you 16 different levels of stimulation of sounds, vibrations, or shocks. The collar is waterproof, and both the remote and collar recharge quickly. The range is 1,970 feet, and the remote can be used for up to two dogs.
Humane use of low-level electronic stimulation for training
“Lock and set” levels 1–100 and boost levels 1–60
Tone and tapping vibration stimulation
Tracking light for night and is waterproof
Can be used for up to two dogs
- Humane use of low-level electronic stimulation for training
- “Lock and set” levels 1–100 and boost levels 1–60
- Tone and tapping vibration stimulation
- Tracking light for night and is waterproof
- Can be used for up to two dogs
Expensive
Training system that takes time
- Expensive
- Training system that takes time
Type: Collar
Size: 7-27-inch necks
Weight: Dogs 10-110 lbs.
Range: 1,970 feet
Method: Noise, vibration, or shocks
However, this collar works better on short-haired dogs, and only the shock feature can be adjusted to different levels, not the tone or vibration features.
Pros
16 levels of stimulation in sounds, vibrations, or shocks
Waterproof collar
Recharges quickly
Works for up to two dogs
Cons
Better on short-haired dogs
Only the shock feature can be adjusted
The Company of Animals Pet Corrector Spray is a spray can filled with air that uses a hissing sound to startle your dog out of barking. Hissing is a sound that some predators use (like snakes), which can distract your dog from any bad behaviors. It is meant to be used in conjunction with a reward (once your dog stops barking, then you give them a treat). It’s a safe and harmless (and painless) method that can help your dog stop barking or other unwanted behaviors.
16 levels of stimulation in sounds, vibrations, or shocks
Waterproof collar
Recharges quickly
Works for up to two dogs
- 16 levels of stimulation in sounds, vibrations, or shocks
- Waterproof collar
- Recharges quickly
- Works for up to two dogs
Better on short-haired dogs
Only the shock feature can be adjusted
- Better on short-haired dogs
- Only the shock feature can be adjusted
Type: Spray
Size: 30, 50, or 200 mL
Weight: N/A
Range: N/A
Method: Hissing sound using air
The disadvantages of this product are that the can gets cold after use, and the spray will not work for all dogs. Some dogs can learn to ignore it, or they will just become fearful of the can.
Pros
Hissing sound using air to startle a barking dog
Used along with a reward-based system
Safe, harmless, and painless
Cons
Spray can gets cold
Doesn’t work for all dogs
Sentry Stop That! Dog Spray uses both a hissing noise and a natural pheromone scent that helps calm and refocus dogs. This also means that the effects of the deterrent tend to last longer than just a noise spray alone. The pheromone works to reduce a dog’s excitability and is a pleasant chamomile and lavender scent.
Hissing sound using air to startle a barking dog
Used along with a reward-based system
Safe, harmless, and painless
- Hissing sound using air to startle a barking dog
- Used along with a reward-based system
- Safe, harmless, and painless
Spray can gets cold
Doesn’t work for all dogs
- Spray can gets cold
- Doesn’t work for all dogs
Type: Spray
Size: 1 oz.
Weight: N/A
Range: N/A
Method: Pheromone and noise
Unfortunately, it is expensive for such a tiny bottle that might not last you long. Also, the sudden hissing noise might scare your dog, which is counterproductive to what the pheromone is meant to do.
Pros
Uses noise and pheromones to calm and refocus dogs
Effects last longer than just a noise spray
Reduces a dog’s excitability
Pleasant lavender and chamomile scent
Cons
Expensive for a small bottle
The sound might counteract the calming pheromone effect
- Stopwoofer Ultrasonic Dog Training Device
Check Latest Price
Type: Remote
Size: N/A
Weight: N/A
Range: 4 feet
Method: Ultrasonic
The Stopwoofer Ultrasonic Dog Training Device is a remote that uses ultrasonic sound to stop your dog from barking. It works on most dogs of all sizes and most ages (recommended is 6 months to 8 years old). The device is generally small enough to fit in your pocket, so you can even use it on the go. It’s rechargeable and can typically last about 14 days on one charge. If the button is pressed for any longer than 8 seconds, the device will automatically shut off for your dog’s safety.
Uses noise and pheromones to calm and refocus dogs
Effects last longer than just a noise spray
Reduces a dog’s excitability
Pleasant lavender and chamomile scent
- Uses noise and pheromones to calm and refocus dogs
- Effects last longer than just a noise spray
- Reduces a dog’s excitability
- Pleasant lavender and chamomile scent
Expensive for a small bottle
The sound might counteract the calming pheromone effect
- Expensive for a small bottle
- The sound might counteract the calming pheromone effect
Check Latest Price
Type: Remote
Size: N/A
Weight: N/A
Range: 4 feet
Method: Ultrasonic
The disadvantages of this device are that some dogs might actually bark more and other dogs might get used to it and it will prove ineffective after a while.
Pros
Uses ultrasonic sound to stop bad behavior
Works on dogs of all sizes
Fits in your pocket
Rechargeable and works for about 14 days on one charge
Shuts off automatically if the button is pressed longer than 8 seconds
Cons
Can make some dogs bark more
Some dogs might adjust after a while
PATPET’s Outdoor Remote Dog Training Collar is available in 1,970 or 3,000 ranges and enables you to choose between shocks, vibrations, or a beeping noise. It gives you 16 levels of shocks or vibrations but can also warn you when the stimulation is becoming too intense for your dog. The transmitter on the collar is rainproof, and the collar is waterproof.
Uses ultrasonic sound to stop bad behavior
Works on dogs of all sizes
Fits in your pocket
Rechargeable and works for about 14 days on one charge
Shuts off automatically if the button is pressed longer than 8 seconds
- Uses ultrasonic sound to stop bad behavior
- Works on dogs of all sizes
- Fits in your pocket
- Rechargeable and works for about 14 days on one charge
- Shuts off automatically if the button is pressed longer than 8 seconds
Can make some dogs bark more
Some dogs might adjust after a while
- Can make some dogs bark more
- Some dogs might adjust after a while
Type: Collar
Size: 8-25inch neck
Weight: Dogs 30-110 lbs.
Range: 1,970 or 3,000 feet
Method: Noise, vibrations, or shocks
However, some of these collars are prone to breaking after a short period. You might find that it won’t turn on after charging it up. Additionally, it isn’t always effective for all dogs.
Pros
1,970- or 3,000-foot ranges available
Choose between beeping, shocks, or vibrations
16 levels of vibrations or shocks
Warns when the stimulation is too much
Rainproof transmitter and waterproof collar
Cons
Might stop working after a short period
Doesn’t work for all dogs
PATPET’s U01 Ultrasonic Pet Behavior Training Remote uses an ultrasonic sound designed to make your dog stop barking. In fact, your dog will hear it, but you won’t because it’s designed for only animals to hear. The remote works for up to 30 feet, so you can use it on your dog while outside. You press the button on the remote when your dog starts barking, and it emits a sound that will make your dog mildly uncomfortable, so it’s safe and painless to use.
1,970- or 3,000-foot ranges available
Choose between beeping, shocks, or vibrations
16 levels of vibrations or shocks
Warns when the stimulation is too much
Rainproof transmitter and waterproof collar
- 1,970- or 3,000-foot ranges available
- Choose between beeping, shocks, or vibrations
- 16 levels of vibrations or shocks
- Warns when the stimulation is too much
- Rainproof transmitter and waterproof collar
Might stop working after a short period
Doesn’t work for all dogs
- Might stop working after a short period
- Doesn’t work for all dogs
Type: Remote
Size: N/A
Weight: N/A
Range: 30 feet
Method: Ultrasonic
However, it won’t work on every dog, and all animals will be affected by this, which isn’t necessarily a good thing. If you have dogs without barking issues or any cats, they might become afraid of it when it’s only meant for the one dog with the behavioral issues.
Pros
Ultrasonic noise to stop dog barking
Only animals will hear it
Remote works up to 30 feet
Makes a sound uncomfortable for dogs but is painless and safe
Cons
Doesn’t work on all dogs
Works on all pets, which isn’t entirely fair
The Safety-Sport XL Dog Horn is a loud air horn that should instantly stop your dog from barking. It can also work double-duty to ensure your and your dog’s safety because it can scare other dogs or animals away if you’re under threat. It should last for approximately 140 short blasts.
Ultrasonic noise to stop dog barking
Only animals will hear it
Remote works up to 30 feet
Makes a sound uncomfortable for dogs but is painless and safe
- Ultrasonic noise to stop dog barking
- Only animals will hear it
- Remote works up to 30 feet
- Makes a sound uncomfortable for dogs but is painless and safe
Doesn’t work on all dogs
Works on all pets, which isn’t entirely fair
- Doesn’t work on all dogs
- Works on all pets, which isn’t entirely fair
Type: Horn
Size: 8 oz.
Weight: N/A
Range: N/A
Method: Loud noise
The main flaw with this product is that it’s probably too loud and scary to actually teach your dog to stop barking. You’ll only teach them to be afraid of the horn, particularly if your dog is already anxious or nervous. Plus, it will wake the household or your neighbors if you need to use it quite early or late.
Pros
Airhorn that will instantly stop your dog from barking
Can also help with safety
Lasts approximately 140 short blasts
Cons
Will likely only scare your dog
You’ll wake everyone up if it’s early or late
Airhorn that will instantly stop your dog from barking
Can also help with safety
Lasts approximately 140 short blasts
- Airhorn that will instantly stop your dog from barking
- Can also help with safety
- Lasts approximately 140 short blasts
Will likely only scare your dog
You’ll wake everyone up if it’s early or late
- Will likely only scare your dog
- You’ll wake everyone up if it’s early or late
Buyer’s Guide – How to Purchase the Best Dog Barking Deterrent
Here, we go over a few points for you to consider before you purchase your barking deterrent.
Size
This only relates to dog collars. Always double-check the recommendations on the product page and the actual measurements. Sometimes the wrong information is put in the description, so it’s always best to check the measurements against your own dog. Some of these collars won’t fit properly on very small dogs or might not be large enough for giant breeds, so always check.
Precautions
Read the precautions before using the collars. Most collars are not meant to be left on your dog at all times. In fact, most recommend that they should only be left on your dog for a minimum of under 6 hours and that you should reposition it on your dog’s neck every 1 to 2 hours. Always read the fine print.
Shock Collars
Don’t let a collar that is advertised as a shock collar necessarily scare you off. Most collars merely have it as an option, so be sure to read the description carefully. For some dogs, it might be the only thing that works for them, so it’s a good idea to go for a collar that has multiple options: noise, vibration, and shock. That said, you should only resort to a shock collar if nothing else is working, and always start at the lowest setting. If you’re truly not comfortable using a shock collar, there are many other options out there.
Why All the Barking?
Before buying a deterrent, you might want to start by figuring out why your dog is barking in the first place. You probably don’t want to hurt or scare your dog, so sometimes, using reward-based training will end up not only being more effective but can also help you form a stronger bond with your dog. Talk to your vet if you’re really concerned, and consider getting an animal behaviorist involved.
- You may also be interested in: 10 Best Bark Collars For Large Dogs in 2022 – Reviews & Top Picks
Conclusion
The Petdiary T720 Dog Training Collar is our overall favorite barking deterrent because it’s well-priced, and it gives you four options to stop your dog from barking: vibration, shock, beeping, and an LED light. The PATPET Remote Dog Training Collar is inexpensive, and you can choose from 16 shock levels, eight vibration levels, or loud beeps. Lastly, the Educator E-Collar Technologies Dog Training Collar is our premium choice pick because it effectively uses humane static stimulation, and you can fine-tune it to the right settings for your dog.
Hopefully, our reviews have brought you a suitable barking deterrent for your pup.
See also:
- 10 Best Dog Seat Covers in 2022 – Reviews & Top Picks!
- 6 Best Dog Colognes in 2022 – Reviews & Top Picks!
- 10 Best Rawhides for Dogs in 2022 – Reviews & Top Picks
Featured Image Credit: PaigeWhite, Shutterstock
