Multi-cat households need multiple litter boxes and, just as important, good quality litter that can stand up to lots of use. What’s the best cat litter for smell? There are many to choose from, in all kinds of materials, which can make deciding on the best one kind of confusing.
These reviews will help you make sense of all the cat litter choices for multi-cat households. We’ll focus on the best odor-eliminating cat litters for high-traffic litter boxes.
Whether you prefer traditional clay litter, clumping litter, high-tech crystals, or natural plant-based litter these reviews have got you—and your cats—covered. Our reviews have been designed for you to select the best cat litter for multiple cats based on your cats.
A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites of 2023
Image Product Details
Best Overall
Kitty Poo Club Clay Litter
Easy to order for multiple cats
Clumping for easy odor-free cleanup
Includes recyclable litter box
Click to Save 20% Use code CAT25
Best Value
Cat’s Pride Total Odor Cat Litter
Low tracking and low dust
Odor control with no added perfume
Check Price
Premium Choice
Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal Cat Litter
Low dust
Traps and destroys odors
Check Price
Best for Kittens
Dr. Elsey’s Kitten Attract Litter
Low dust
Multi-cat formula
Made specifically for kittens
Check Price
Naturally Fresh Walnut Litter
Natural odor control
All-natural and sustainable
Check Price
The 10 Best Cat Litters for Multiple Cats
1. Kitty Poo Club Clay Cat Litter – Best Overall
Save 20% off first litter box order with code CAT20
Material: Clay
Odor control: Excellent
Clumping: Yes
If you have multiple cats, you don’t want to spend all of your time scrubbing litter boxes. That’s why our pick for overall best cat litter for multiple cats is Kitty Poo Club’s Clay Cat Litter. This company is unique because it sends you excellent low dust, hypoallergenic clay cat litter and recyclable litter boxes. Just order multiple boxes from Kitty Poo Club and relax!
These boxes are eco-friendly and easy to use. The litter does a great job of absorbing odors, and it clumps well for easy scooping. If you have more than one cat, we think you’ll love Kitty Poo Club!
Pros
Clumping for an easy cleanup
Low dust and hypoallergenic
Easy to order for multiple cats
Includes convenient recyclable litter box
No litter box scrubbing required
Cons
Unscented
Subscription-based
Our pick for best cat litter for multiple cats for the money is Cat’s Pride Total Odor Control Unscented Clumping Clay Cat Litter. This economical litter is unscented and contains no dyes or perfumes, but it has an odor trapping formula that works for up to 10 days. It’s also 25% lighter in weight than other clumping litters to make pouring easier.
Clumping for an easy cleanup
Low dust and hypoallergenic
Easy to order for multiple cats
Includes convenient recyclable litter box
No litter box scrubbing required
- Clumping for an easy cleanup
- Low dust and hypoallergenic
- Easy to order for multiple cats
- Includes convenient recyclable litter box
- No litter box scrubbing required
Unscented
Subscription-based
- Unscented
- Subscription-based
Material: Clay
Odor control: 10-day odor control
Clumping: Yes
Check Price on Chewy
Pros
Odor control with no added perfume
Low tracking and low dust
Cons
Some consumers report it sticks to their cats’ paws
3. Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal Cat Litter – Premium Choice
Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal Platinum Cat Litter, Multi-Cat is a premium litter that combines clumping clay with baking soda and other odor-eliminating ingredients. It’s designed to seal in and eliminate litter box odors from urine and feces on contact. It has no added fragrance for cats with sensitive noses.
Odor control with no added perfume
Low tracking and low dust
- Odor control with no added perfume
- Low tracking and low dust
Some consumers report it sticks to their cats’ paws
- Some consumers report it sticks to their cats’ paws
Material: Clay
Odor control: 7-day odor control guarantee
Clumping: Yes
Pros
Traps and destroys odors
Low dust
Cons
Some consumers report that it is high tracking
- Dr. Elsey’s Kitten Attract Clay Cat Litter – Best for Kittens
Check Latest Price
Material: Clay
Odor control: Natural chlorophyll
Clumping: Yes
Dr. Elsey’s Kitten Attract Clumping Clay Cat Litter is one of the few litters created specifically for kittens. It has a delicate granule size and texture for a kitten’s tiny paws. It also contains an herbal attractant designed to encourage kittens to use the box. It has natural chlorophyll-based odor control.
Traps and destroys odors
Low dust
- Traps and destroys odors
- Low dust
Some consumers report that it is high tracking
- Some consumers report that it is high tracking
Check Latest Price
Material: Clay
Odor control: Natural chlorophyll
Clumping: Yes
Pros
Multi-cat formula
Made specifically for kittens
Low dust
Cons
Fine granules may get in your cat’s fur
The Naturally Fresh Walnut Shell Cat Litter, Multi-Cat Ultra Odor Control is an eco-friendly multi-cat litter made from walnut shells. The odor control comes from a moisture-activated probiotic that neutralizes all types of litter box odors on contact. It’s a biodegradable plant-based litter that contains no toxins.
Multi-cat formula
Made specifically for kittens
Low dust
- Multi-cat formula
- Made specifically for kittens
- Low dust
Fine granules may get in your cat’s fur
- Fine granules may get in your cat’s fur
Material: Walnut shell
Odor control: Probiotic odor control
Clumping: Yes
Pros
All-natural and sustainable
Natural odor control
Cons
Produces brown dust that can be visible on surfaces and white fur
- Scoop Away Complete Performance Clumping Clay Cat Litter
Check Latest Price
Material: Clay
Odor control: 10-day odor control guarantee
Clumping: Yes
The Scoop Away Complete Performance Fresh Scented Clumping Clay Cat Litter uses scent and natural plant extracts to remove all types of litter box odors for up to 10 days. The fragrance is paw-activated when your cats use the box.
All-natural and sustainable
Natural odor control
- All-natural and sustainable
- Natural odor control
Produces brown dust that can be visible on surfaces and white fur
- Produces brown dust that can be visible on surfaces and white fur
Material: Clay
Odor control: 10-day odor control guarantee
Clumping: Yes
Pros
Natural odor control
Scented
Cons
Some consumers complain of dust
World’s Best Cat Litter Multiple Cat Lavender Scented is made from corn that’s compressed into absorbent granules. It’s flushable and safe for septic and sewer systems. The added scent is from natural lavender oil and helps with odor control.
Natural odor control
Scented
- Natural odor control
- Scented
Some consumers complain of dust
- Some consumers complain of dust
Material: Corn
Odor control: Lavender oil
Clumping: Yes
Pros
Natural fragrance
Plant-based
Flushable
Cons
Some cats may not like the scent
8. Fresh Step Febreze Scented Non-Clumping Clay Cat Litter
The Fresh Step Febreze Scented Non-Clumping Clay Cat Litter is a traditional non-clumping clay litter that’s a good choice for multiple cat households because it has 2 forms of odor control: activated charcoal and Febreze scent that’s released when your cats scratch.
Natural fragrance
Plant-based
Flushable
- Natural fragrance
- Plant-based
- Flushable
Some cats may not like the scent
- Some cats may not like the scent
Material: Clay
Odor control: 7-day odor control
Clumping: No
Pros
Scent and charcoal for odor control
Low dust
Cons
Some cats may not like the scent
- Frisco Multi-Cat Non-Clumping Scented Crystal Cat Litter
Check Latest Price
Material: Crystal
Odor control: Odor locking crystals
Clumping: No
The Frisco Multi-Cat Non-Clumping Scented Crystal Cat Litter is made with silica gel crystals that have tiny pores designed to absorb and lock in liquid and odor. It is also scented for additional odor control. The crystals are low dust and gentle on your cats’ feet.
Scent and charcoal for odor control
Low dust
- Scent and charcoal for odor control
- Low dust
Material: Crystal
Odor control: Odor locking crystals
Clumping: No
Pros
Scented
Absorbs odors
Cons
Some cats dislike crystal litter
Tidy Cats Instant Action Scented Clumping Clay Cat Litter is a popular clumping clay litter that comes in several varieties. This one is good for multiple cats because it has an instant-action deodorizing system that neutralizes all kinds of litter box odors. It also has a scent for added odor control.
Scented
Absorbs odors
- Scented
- Absorbs odors
Some cats dislike crystal litter
- Some cats dislike crystal litter
Pros
Scented
Good odor control
Cons
Some consumers report clumps breaking up
Buyer’s Guide: Finding the Best Cat Litter for Multiple Cats
Choosing the right litter for your multi-cat household can be a challenge. Not only should the litter be effective at odor control, but your cats must like it enough to use it. Sometimes a cat can be turned off by a litter’s texture or scent. Here are some tips for finding your best cat litter for multiple cats.
Scented
Good odor control
- Scented
- Good odor control
Some consumers report clumps breaking up
- Some consumers report clumps breaking up
Try Different Types
It can be hard to predict what type of litter your cats will prefer until you try a few kinds. Studies have shown that cats tend to prefer litter with a soft, fine texture, like sand. But cats are individuals, so there’s no guarantee all your cats will like the same kind of litter.
Some cats don’t mind scented litter, others do. And cats will be hesitant to use any type of litter if isn’t clean.
Maintain a Regular Cleaning Schedule
Regular cleaning is important no matter what type of litter you choose. Many owners like clumping litter for easy cleaning, but you’ll still have to scoop out the clumps and solid waste every day.
You’ll also have to completely change out the litter regularly. Even if a brand of litter promises long-lasting odor control, litter in a multi-cat home gets lots of use so you may have to change it out more frequently than you think.
It’s always a good idea to thoroughly clean the box with warm soapy water every time you change the litter.
If you’re over your house smelling like you’ve got a pet, it’s time to check out the Hepper Advanced Bio-Enzyme Pet Stain & Odor Eliminator Spray! It removes even the most stubborn smells and stains and comes with a 100% satisfaction guarantee. Click here to find out more about this amazing product.At Pet Keen, we’ve admired Hepper for many years, and decided to take a controlling ownership interest so that we could benefit from the outstanding products of this cool cat company!
Multiple Litter Boxes
Another important factor with multiple cats is having enough litter boxes to go around. Many experts suggest 1 box per cat plus 1 extra, if possible. Try to place them in quiet, low-traffic areas.
Your preferences can be just as important as your cats’ when it comes to litter. Some may just not work for you, either because of poor odor control, a lot of dust, or some other reason.
If you or your cats don’t like a particular litter, try another one with a different texture or scent.
Clumping vs Clay?
Clumping clay litters are very popular, and many stores have a lot of different ones to choose from, but clay isn’t the only option. You can also experiment with non-clay litters. They may seem different at first, but you and your cats might find a winner.
With a little patience, you can find the right litter for everyone—human and feline—in your home.
Conclusion
Good quality litter is important to the cats and people living in a multi-cat home. Here’s a summary of a few of the top picks from our reviews.
We like Kitty Poo Club’s Clay Litter because it’s got all the bells and whistles for multi-cat households. The included recyclable litter boxes mean you won’t have to spend time scrubbing, and the low dust, hypoallergenic clay litter works wonders on odors. Plus, it’s clumping for easier cleaning, making it our overall best cat litter for multiple cats.
Another top pick is Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal Platinum. It contains odor-absorbing baking soda plus other odor control ingredients, and it contains no fragrance if a scent is an issue with your cats.
A good non-clay option is the Naturally Fresh litter brand made from walnut shells. It’s a plant-based litter that uses probiotics for odor control.
Featured Image Credit: Zoran-Photographer, Shutterstock
